×

Effects of numerical dissipation on the interpretation of simulation results in computational fluid dynamics. (English) Zbl 1390.76556

Summary: The accuracy of direct and large-eddy simulations (DNS and LES) is typically assessed through a time consuming process of multiple runs and comparisons with available benchmark data. The goal is to achieve physically representative results by minimizing truncation errors in DNS, along with subgrid-scale modeling errors when performing LES. We show that even if these errors cannot be neglected, the physical accuracy can be improved if the numerical dissipation is properly accounted for in interpreting the results. Based on the balance of kinetic energy proposed by F. S. Schranner et al. [ibid. 114, 84–97 (2015; Zbl 1390.76513)], the method allows to compute the numerical dissipation rate and the numerical viscosity at each time step in a simulation for an arbitrary computational fluid dynamics (CFD) solver. We demonstrate that the quantitative knowledge of the numerical dissipation can be employed to better understand results obtained using dissipative CFD codes. We consider two different cases: DNS for a weakly turbulent wake past a sphere at \(\mathrm{Re} = 1000\) performed using the OpenFOAM solver, and LES of a laminar separation bubble flow at \(\mathrm{Re} = 100,000\) performed using a compact difference solver with stabilizing filters. The procedure is used to show that results of nominally under-resolved DNS (UDNS) can be re-interpreted as corresponding to LES results or to DNS results but for a different, effective Reynolds number that accounts for the total dissipation, consisting of the numerical dissipation and of the viscous dissipation. In both cases, comparison with benchmark data is much improved compared with cases when the nominal values used in the code are employed.

MSC:

76M20 Finite difference methods applied to problems in fluid mechanics
65M06 Finite difference methods for initial value and initial-boundary value problems involving PDEs
76F65 Direct numerical and large eddy simulation of turbulence
76N15 Gas dynamics (general theory)

Citations:

Zbl 1390.76513

Software:

OpenFOAM
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Brouwer, J.; Reiss, J.; Sesterhenn, J., Conservative time integrators of arbitrary order for skew-symmetric finite-difference discretizations of compressible flow, Comput Fluids, 100, 1-12, (2014) · Zbl 1391.76463
[2] Cadieux, F.; Domaradzki, J. A.; Sayadi, T.; Bose, T., DNS and LES of laminar separation bubbles at moderate Reynolds numbers, J Fluids Eng, 136, 6, (2014)
[3] Cadieux, F.; Domaradzki, J. A.; Sayadi, T.; Bose, T.; Duchaine, F., DNS and LES of separated flows at moderate Reynolds numbers, Proceedings of the 2012 Summer Program, Center for Turbulence Research, 77-86, (2012)
[4] Castiglioni, G.; Domaradzki, J., A numerical dissipation rate and viscosity in flow simulations with realistic geometry using low-order compressible Navier-Stokes solvers, Comput Fluids, 119, 37-46, (2015) · Zbl 1390.76137
[5] Domaradzki, J.; Radhakrishnan, S., Effective eddy viscosities in implicit modeling of decaying high Reynolds number turbulence with and without rotation, Fluid Dyn Res, 36, 385-406, (2005) · Zbl 1153.76374
[6] Domaradzki, J. A.; Xiao, Z.; Smolarkiewicz, P. K., Effective eddy viscosities in implicit large eddy simulations of turbulent flows, Phys Fluids, 15, 12, 3890-3893, (2003) · Zbl 1186.76146
[7] Grinstein, F. F.; Margolin, L. G.; Rider, W. J., Implicit large eddy simulation: computing turbulent fluid dynamics, (2007), Cambridge University Press · Zbl 1135.76001
[8] Ham, F.; Lien, F.; Strong, A., A fully conservative second-order finite difference scheme for incompressible flow on nonuniform grids, J Comp Phys, 177, 1, 117-133, (2002) · Zbl 1066.76044
[9] Hickel, S.; Adams, N.; Domaradzki, J., An adaptive local deconvolution method for implicit LES, J Comp Phys, 213, 413-436, (2006) · Zbl 1146.76607
[10] Kim, H. J.; Durbin, P. A., Observations of the frequencies in a sphere wake and of drag increase by acoustic excitation, Phys Fluids, 31, 3260-3265, (1988)
[11] Kravchenko, A.; Moin, P., On the effect of numerical errors in large eddy simulations of turbulent flows, J Comp Phys, 131, 2, 310-322, (1997) · Zbl 0872.76074
[12] Lele, S. K., Compact finite difference schemes with spectral like resolution, J Comp Phys, 103, 16-42, (1992) · Zbl 0759.65006
[13] Nagarajan, S.; Lele, S. K.; Ferziger, J. H., A robust high-order compact method for large eddy simulation, J Comp Phys, 191, 392-419, (2003) · Zbl 1051.76030
[14] Nagarajan, S.; Lele, S. K.; Ferziger, J. H., Leading-edge effects in bypass transition, J Fluid Mech, 572, 471-504, (2007) · Zbl 1145.76025
[15] Nicoud, F.; Toda, H. B.; Cabrit, O.; Bose, S.; Lee, J., Using singular values to build a subgrid-scale model for large eddy simulations, Phys Fluids, 23, 8, (2011)
[16] Orr, T. S.; Domaradzki, J. A.; Spedding, G. R.; Constantinescu, G. S., Numerical simulations of the near wake of a sphere moving in a steady, horizontal motion through a linearly stratified fluid at \(\operatorname{Re} = 1000\), Phys Fluids, 27, 3, (2015)
[17] Poroseva, S.; Colmenares Fernandez, J. D.; Murman, S., On the accuracy of RANS simulations with DNS data, Phys Fluids, 28, (2016)
[18] Poroseva, S.; Jeyapaul, E.; Murman, S.; Colmenares Fernandez, J. D., The effect of the DNS data averaging time on the accuracy of RANS-DNS simulations, 46th AIAA Fluid Dynamics Conference. Paper AIAA, 2016-3940, (2016)
[19] Reiss, J.; Sesterhenn, J., A conservative, skew-symmetric finite difference scheme for the compressible Navier-Stokes equations, Comput Fluids, 101, 208-219, (2014) · Zbl 1391.76490
[20] Sagaut, P., Large eddy simulation for incompressible flows, (2006), Springer Berlin, Germany
[21] Schranner, F. S.; Domaradzki, J. A.; Hickel, S.; Adams, N. A., Assessing the numerical dissipation rate and viscosity in numerical simulations of fluid flows, Comput Fluids, 114, 0, 84-97, (2015) · Zbl 1390.76513
[22] Spalart, P.; Strelets, M., Mechanisms of transition and heat transfer in a separation bubble, J Fluid Mech, 403, 329-349, (2000) · Zbl 0972.76046
[23] Subbareddy, P. K.; Candler, G. V., A fully discrete, kinetic energy consistent finite-volume scheme for compressible flows, J Comp Phys, 228, 5, 1347-1364, (2009) · Zbl 1157.76029
[24] Sun, G.; Domaradzki, J.; Xiang, X.; Chen, K., Assessing accuracy of CFD simulations through quantification of a numerical dissipation rate, In: TSFP-10, (2017)
[25] Tantikul, T.; Domaradzki, J., Large eddy simulations using truncated - equations with the automatic filtering criterion, J Turb, 11, 21, 1-24, (2010)
[26] Tomboulides, A. G.; Orszag, S. A., Numerical investigation of transitional and weak turbulent flow past a sphere, J Fluid Mech, 416, 45-73, (2000) · Zbl 1156.76419
[27] Xiang X., Chen K., Madison T., Sellappan P., Spedding G.. Experiments and simulations of low Re sphere wakes with and without stratification. In:VIIIth international symposium on stratified flows. UC San Diego, San Diego, CA. 2016.; Xiang X., Chen K., Madison T., Sellappan P., Spedding G.. Experiments and simulations of low Re sphere wakes with and without stratification. In:VIIIth international symposium on stratified flows. UC San Diego, San Diego, CA. 2016.
[28] Zhou, Y., Renormalization group theory for fluid and plasma turbulence, Phys Rep, 488, 1-49, (2010)
[29] Zhou, Y.; Grinstein, F. F.; Wachtor, A. J.; Haines, B. M., Estimating the effective Reynolds number in implicit large-eddy simulation, Phys Rev E, 89, (2014)
[30] Zhou, Y.; Thornber, B., A comparison of three approaches to compute the effective Reynolds number of the implicit large-eddy simulations, ASME J Fluids Eng, 138, (2016)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.