The impact of spatial interpolation techniques on spatial basis risk for weather insurance: an application to forage crops. (English) Zbl 1426.91204

Summary: Weather index insurance for crops is at the developmental stage, however, this type of insurance is particularly susceptible to the problem of spatial basis risk. Spatial basis risk occurs when the weather observed at weather stations does not match the weather experienced on the farmer’s property, causing improper indemnities to be paid to the farmer. However, spatial basis risk may be reduced through the use of averaging and spatial interpolation techniques, such as inverse distance weighting and kriging. These techniques make it possible to incorporate multiple weather stations in the estimation process rather than using only the single closest station, potentially resulting in more accurate estimations and thereby reducing spatial basis risk. Therefore, the objective of this study is to examine the extent to which the choice of spatial interpolation techniques can influence the amount of spatial basis risk in a weather-based insurance model. Using forage crops from the province of Ontario, Canada, as an example, a weather insurance index is developed based on cooling degree days. The weather index represents the heat stress that the crops receive over the growing season. This insurance index is used to determine to what extent spatial basis risk can be reduced by the insurer’s choice of spatial interpolation technique. Seven different interpolation methods are applied to temperature data from Ontario, and theoretical indemnities are calculated for forage producers across the province. By analyzing the correlation between the estimated indemnities and reported forage yields, the amount of spatial basis risk in each model is quantified. The results of this study highlight the importance of choosing an appropriate method based on the characteristics of the target region (and data). Operationally this is important because insurers typically apply the same interpolation methods across an entire region. While one finding of this research may suggest that governments and/or insurance companies may wish to invest in additional weather stations to improve the accuracy of the interpolation method and index, this may not be feasible in practice. Given this, future research may consider utilizing satellite-based remote sensing weather estimates to augment the weather station data and reduce basis risk.


91G05 Actuarial mathematics
62P05 Applications of statistics to actuarial sciences and financial mathematics
Full Text: DOI Link


[1] Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC), Evaluation of the agriInsurance, private sector risk management partnerships and wildlife compensation programs. Technical report (2012)
[2] Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC), Forage Statistics Technical report (2012)
[3] Bhunia, G. S.; Shit, P. K.; Maiti, R., Comparison of GIS-based interpolation methods for spatial distribution of soil organic carbon (SOC, Journal of the Saudi Society of Agricultural Sciences (2018)
[4] Black, E.; Tarnavsky, E.; Maidment, R.; Greatrex, H.; Mookerjee, A.; Quaife, T.; Brown, M., The use of remotely sensed rainfall for managing drought risk: A case study of weather index insurance in Zambia, Remote Sensing, 8, 4, 342 (2016)
[5] Boyd, M.; Pai, J.; Zhang, Q.; Wang, H.; Wang, K., Factors affecting crop insurance purchases in China: The Inner Mongolia region, China Agricultural Economic Review, 3, 4, 441-50 (2011)
[6] Brown, D. P.; Comrie., A. C., Spatial modeling of winter temperature and precipitation in Arizona and New Mexico, USA, Climate Research, 22, 2, 115-128 (2002)
[7] Buxton, D.; Kenelly, J., Growing quality forages under variable environmental conditions, Proceedings of the Western Canadian Dairy Seminar (1995), Edmonton, AB, Canada: University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada
[8] Cai, R.; Mullen, J. D.; Bergstrom, J. C.; Shurley, W. D.; Wetzstein., M. E., Using a climate index to measure crop yield response, Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 45, 4, 719 (2013)
[9] Cao, X.; Okhrin, O.; Odening, M.; Ritter., M., Modelling spatio-temporal variability of temperature, Computational Statistics, 30, 3, 745-66 (2015) · Zbl 1342.65022
[10] Carter, M.; De Janvry, A.; Sadoulet, E.; Sarris., A., Index-based weather insurance for developing countries: A review of evidence and a set of propositions for up-scaling (2014), Development Policies Working Paper, 111
[11] Chamberlain, S., rgbif: Interface to the global ’biodiversity’ information facility ’api’ (Computer software manual). R package version 0.9.5 (2016)
[12] Chantarat, S.; Mude, A. G.; Barrett, C. B.; Turvey., C. G., The performance of index based livestock insurance (2009), Ex ante assessment in the presence of a poverty trap
[13] Chen, D.; Ou, T.; Gong, L.; Xu, C.-Y.; Li, W.; Ho,, C.-H., Spatial interpolation of daily precipitation in China: 1951-2005, Advances in Atmospheric Sciences, 27, 6, 1221-32 (2010)
[14] Chen, F.; Liu., C., Estimation of the spatial rainfall distribution using inverse distance weighting (IDW) in the middle of Taiwan, Paddy and Water Environment, 10, 3, 209-22 (2012)
[15] Chien, Y.-J.; Lee, D.-Y.; Guo, H.-Y.; Houng., K.-H., Geostatistical analysis of soil properties of mid-west Taiwan soils, Soil Science, 162, 4, 291-98 (1997)
[16] Clarke, D. J., A theory of rational demand for index insurance, American Economic Journal: Microeconomics, 8, 1, 283-306 (2016)
[17] Clarke, D. J.; Clarke, D.; Mahul, O.; Rao, K. N.; Verma., N., Weather- based crop insurance in India. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper no. 5985 (2012), Washington Dc: World Bank, Washington Dc
[18] Cressie, N., Spatial prediction and ordinary kriging, Mathematical Geology, 20, 4, 405-21 (1988) · Zbl 0970.86517
[19] Dick, W.; Stoppa., A., Weather index-based insurance in agricultural development: A technical guide (2011), International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD
[20] Dirks, K.; Hay, J.; Stow, C.; Harris., D., High-resolution studies of rainfall on Norfolk Island: Part II: Interpolation of rainfall data, Journal of Hydrology, 208, 3, 187-93 (1998)
[21] Eischeid, J. K.; Pasteris, P. A.; Diaz, H. F.; Plantico, M. S.; Lott., N. J., Creating a serially complete, national daily time series of temperature and precipitation for the western United States, Journal of Applied Meteorology, 39, 9, 1580-91 (2000)
[22] El Kenawy, A.; López-Moreno, J. I.; Vicente-Serrano, S. M.; Morsi., F., Climatological modeling of monthly air temperature and precipitation in Egypt through GIS techniques, Climate Research, 42, 2, 161-76 (2010)
[23] SRI Environmental Systems Research Institute ESRI, Arcgis desktop (Computer software manual). Redlands, California (2016)
[24] Erdogan, S., A comparision of interpolation methods for producing digital elevation models at the field scale, Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 34, 3, 366-76 (2009)
[25] Erhardt, R. J.; Smith., R. L., Weather derivative risk measures for extreme events, North American Actuarial Journal, 18, 3, 379-93 (2014) · Zbl 1414.91371
[26] Golden, L. L.; Yang, C. C.; Zou., H., The effectiveness of using a basis hedging strategy to mitigate the financial consequences of weather-related risks, North American Actuarial Journal, 14, 2, 157-75 (2010)
[27] Heimfarth, L. E.; Musshoff., O., Weather index-based insurances for farmers in the North China Plain: An analysis of risk reduction potential and basis risk, Agricultural Finance Review, 71, 2, 218-39 (2011)
[28] Hengl, T., A practical guide to geostatistical mapping, Vol. 52 (2009), Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg
[29] Herdendorf, C. E., Large lakes of the world, Journal of Great Lakes Research, 8, 3, 379-412 (1982)
[30] Hofstra, N.; Haylock, M.; New, M.; Jones, P.; Frei, C., Comparison of six methods for the interpolation of daily, European climate data, Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 113, D21 (2008)
[31] Holdaway, M. R., Spatial modeling and interpolation of monthly temperature using kriging, Climate Research, 06, 3, 215-25 (1996)
[32] Jensen, N. D.; Barrett, C. B.; Mude., A. G., Index insurance quality and basis risk: Evidence from northern Kenya, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 98, 5, 1450-69 (2016)
[33] Jiang, W.; Li, J. (2014)
[34] Joseph, V. R.; Kang., L., Regression-based inverse distance weighting with applications to computer experiments, Technometrics, 53, 3, 254-65 (2011)
[35] Kilibarda, M.; Hengl, T.; Heuvelink, G.; Gräler, B.; Pebesma, E.; Perčec Tadić,, M., Spatio-temporal interpolation of daily temperatures for global land areas at 1 km resolution, Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 119, 5, 2294-313 (2014)
[36] Kuzyakova, I.; Romanenkov, V.; Kuzyakov, Y. V., Geostatistics in soil agrochemical studies, Eurasian Soil Science, 34, 9, 1011-7 (2001)
[37] Li, J.; Heap, A. D., A review of spatial interpolation methods for environmental scientists (2008), Canberra: Geoscience Australia, Canberra
[38] Li, J. L.; Zhang, J.; Zhang, C.; Chen., Q. G., Analyze and compare the spatial interpolation methods for climate factor, Pratacultural Science, 8 (2006)
[39] Lin, J.; Boyd, M.; Pai, J.; Porth, L.; Zhang, Q.; Wang., K., Factors affecting farmers’ willingness to purchase weather index insurance in the Hainan Province of China, Agricultural Finance Review, 75, 1, 103-13 (2015)
[40] Mahul, O.; Skees., J., Managing agricultural risk at the country level: The case of index-based livestock insurance in Mongolia (2007), Washington, DC: World Bank, Washington, DC
[41] Mair, A.; Fares, A., Comparison of rainfall interpolation methods in a mountainous region of a tropical island, Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 16, 4, 371-83 (2010)
[42] Major, J.; Froot, K. A., The financing of catastrophe risk, Index hedge performance: Insurer market penetration and basis risk, 391-432 (1999), Chicago: University of Chicago Press, Chicago
[43] Makaudze, E. M.; Miranda, M. J., Catastrophic drought insurance based on the remotely sensed normalised difference vegetation index for smallholder farmers in Zimbabwe, Agrekon, 49, 4, 418-32 (2010)
[44] Mccarl, B. A.; Villavicencio, X.; Wu, X., Climate change and future analysis: Is stationarity dying? American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 90, 5, 1241-7 (2008)
[45] Mobarak, A. M.; Rosenzweig., M. R. (2012)
[46] Nalder, I. A.; Wein, R. W., Spatial interpolation of climatic normals: Test of a new method in the Canadian boreal forest, Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 92, 4, 211-25 (1998)
[47] Norton, M.; Osgood, D.; Turvey, C. G., Weather index insurance and the pricing of spatial basis risk (2010)
[48] Norton, M. T.; Turvey, C.; Osgood, D., Quantifying spatial basis risk for weather index insurance, Journal of Risk Finance, 14, 1, 20-34 (2012)
[49] Nusret, D.; Dug, S., Applying the inverse distance weighting and kriging methods of the spatial interpolation on the mapping the annual precipitation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Ph.D. diss (2012), International Environmental Modelling and Software Society (iEMSs
[50] Odening, M.; Shen, Z., Challenges of insuring weather risk in agriculture, Agricultural Finance Review, 74, 2, 188-99 (2014)
[51] Okhrin, O.; Odening, M.; Xu, W., Systemic weather risk and crop insurance: The case of China, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 80, 2, 351-72 (2013)
[52] Paulson, N. D.; Hart, C. E. (2006)
[53] Porth, C. B.; Porth, L.; Zhu, W.; Boyd, M. S.; Tan, K. S.; Lui., K., Remote sensing applications for insurance (2018), A predictive model for pasture yield in the presence of systemic weather
[54] Porth, L.; Tan, K. S., Agricultural insurance — More room to grow? The Actuary, 12, 2, 36-41 (2015)
[55] Rowley, R. J.; Price, K. P.; Kastens, J. H., Remote sensing and the rancher: Linking rancher perception and remote sensing, Rangeland Ecology & Management, 60, 4, 359-68 (2007)
[56] Shields, D. A., Agricultural Disaster Assistance, CRS Report RS21212 (2015), Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service, Washington, DC
[57] Shope, C. L.; Maharjan., G. R., Modeling spatiotemporal precipitation: Effects of density, interpolation, and land use distribution (2015), Advances in Meteorology
[58] Sun, Y.; Kang, S.; Li, F.; Zhang, L., Comparison of interpolation methods for depth to groundwater and its temporal and spatial variations in the Minqin Oasis of Northwest China, Environmental Modelling & Software, 24, 10, 1163-70 (2009)
[59] Turvey, C. G.; Mclaurin, M. K., Applicability of the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) in index-based crop insurance design, Weather, Climate, and Society, 4, 4, 271-84 (2012)
[60] Veness, C., Calculate distance and bearing between two latitude/longitude points using Haversine formula in javascript (2011)
[61] Weng, Q., An evaluation of spatial interpolation accuracy of elevation data (2006), Berlin: Springer, Berlin
[62] Wu, T.; Li, Y., Spatial interpolation of temperature in the United States using residual kriging, Applied Geography, 44, 112-20 (2013)
[63] Zhu, Q.; Lin, H., Comparing ordinary kriging and regression kriging for soil properties in contrasting landscapes, Pedosphere, 20, 5, 594-606 (2010)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.