Mitigating interest rate risk in variable annuities: an analysis of hedging effectiveness under model risk. (English) Zbl 1414.91159

Summary: Variable annuities are investment vehicles offered by insurance companies that combine a life insurance policy with long-term financial guarantees. These guarantees expose the insurer to market risks, such as volatility and interest rate risks, which can be managed only with a hedging strategy. The objective of this article is to study the effectiveness of dynamic delta-rho hedging strategies for mitigating interest rate risk in variable annuities with either a guaranteed minimum death benefit or guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit rider. Our analysis centers on three important practical issues: (1) the robustness of delta-rho hedging strategies to model uncertainty, (2) the impact of guarantee features (maturity versus withdrawal benefits) on the performance of the hedging strategy, and (3) the importance of hedging interest rate risk in either a low and stable or rising interest rate environment. Overall, we find that the impact of interest rate risk is equally felt for the two types of products considered, and that interest rate hedges do lead to a significant risk reduction for the insurer, even when the ongoing low interest rate environment is factored in.


91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
91G30 Interest rates, asset pricing, etc. (stochastic models)


Full Text: DOI


[1] Ahmad, R.; Wilmott, P., Which Free Lunch Would You Like Today, Sir?: Delta Hedging, Volatility Arbitrage and Optimal Portfolios, Wilmott Magazine, 64-79, (2005)
[2] Alexander, C.; Kaeck, A., Does Model Fit Matter for Hedging? Evidence from FTSE 100 Options, Journal of Futures Markets, 32, 7, 609-638, (2012)
[3] Alexander, C.; Rubinov, A.; Kalepky, M.; Leontsinis, S., Regime-Dependent Smile-Adjusted Delta Hedging, Journal of Futures Markets, 32, 3, 203-229, (2012)
[4] Augustyniak, M.; Boudreault, M., An Out-of-Sample Analysis of Investment Guarantees for Equity-Linked Products: Lessons from the Financial Crisis of the Late 2000s, North American Actuarial Journal, 16, 2, 183-206, (2012)
[5] Augustyniak, M.; Boudreault, M., On the Importance of Hedging Dynamic Lapses in Variable Annuities, Society of Actuaries—Risks & Rewards Newsletter, 16, 12-16, (2015)
[6] Bacinello, A. R.; Millossovich, P.; Olivieri, A.; Pitacco, E., Variable Annuities: A Unifying Valuation Approach, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 49, 3, 285-297, (2011)
[7] Bacinello, A. R.; Ortu, F.; Peccati, ed. L.; Virén, M., Financial Modelling, Contributions to Management Science, Single and Periodic Premiums for Guaranteed Equity-Linked Life Insurance under Interest-Rate Risk: The “Lognormal + Vasicek” Case, 1-25, (1994), Heidelberg: Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg
[8] Bakshi, G.; Cao, C.; Chen, Z., Empirical Performance of Alternative Option Pricing Models, Journal of Finance, 52, 5, 2003-2049, (1997)
[9] Bakshi, G.; Cao, C.; Chen, Z., Pricing and Hedging Long-Term Options, Journal of Econometrics, 94, 1-2, 277-318, (2000) · Zbl 0989.91041
[10] Bakshi, G.; Kapadia, N., Delta-Hedged Gains and the Negative Market Volatility Risk Premium, Review of Financial Studies, 16, 2, 527-566, (2003)
[11] Bauer, D.; Kling, A.; Ruß, J., A Universal Pricing Framework for Guaranteed Minimum Benefits in Variable Annuities, ASTIN Bulletin, 38, 2, 621-651, (2008) · Zbl 1274.91399
[12] Becker, R.; Clements, A. E.; White, S. I., On the Informational Efficiency of S&P500 Implied Volatility, North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 17, 2, 139-153, (2006)
[13] Brigo, D.; Mercurio, F., Interest Rate Models—Theory and Practice, (2006), Berlin: Springer, Berlin · Zbl 1109.91023
[14] Britten-Jones, M.; Neuberger, A., Option Prices, Implied Price Processes, and Stochastic Volatility, Journal of Finance, 55, 2, 839-866, (2000)
[15] Busch, T.; Christensen, B. J.; Nielsen, M. Ø., The Role of Implied Volatility in Forecasting Future Realized Volatility and Jumps in Foreign Exchange, Stock, and Bond Markets, Journal of Econometrics, 160, 1, 48-57, (2011) · Zbl 1441.62620
[16] Report of the Task Force on Segregated Fund Liability and Capital Methodologies, (2010), Ottawa: CIA, Ottawa
[17] Guidance for the 2016 Valuation of Insurance Contract Liabilities of Life Insurers, (2016), Ottawa: CIA, Ottawa
[18] Carr, P.; Wu, L., A Tale of Two Indices, Journal of Derivatives, 13, 3, 13-29, (2006)
[19] Carr, P.; Wu, L., Variance Risk Premiums, Review of Financial Studies, 22, 3, 1311-1341, (2009)
[20] Cathcart, M. J.; Yen Lok, H.; McNeil, A. J.; Morrison, S., Calculating Variable Annuity Liability “Greeks” using Monte Carlo Simulation, ASTIN Bulletin, 45, 2, 239-266, (2015) · Zbl 1390.91332
[21] The CBOE Volatility Index—VIX, (2015)
[22] Chen, R.-R.; Scott, L., Multi-Factor Cox-Ingersoll-Ross Models of the Term Structure: Estimates and Tests from a Kalman Filter Model, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 27, 2, 143-172, (2003)
[23] Chen, Z.; Vetzal, K.; Forsyth, P., The Effect of Modelling Parameters on the Value of GMWB Guarantees, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 43, 1, 165-173, (2008) · Zbl 1141.91024
[24] Chernov, M., On the Role of Risk Premia in Volatility Forecasting, Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 25, 4, 411-426, (2007)
[25] Coleman, T. F.; Li, Y.; Patron, M.-C., Hedging Guarantees in Variable Annuities under Both Equity and Interest Rate Risks, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 38, 2, 215-228, (2006) · Zbl 1128.91020
[26] Dickson, D. C. M.; Hardy, M. R.; Waters, H. R., Actuarial Mathematics for Life Contingent Risks, (2013), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Cambridge · Zbl 1271.91001
[27] Donnelly, R.; Jaimungal, S.; Rubisov, D. H., Valuing Guaranteed Withdrawal Benefits with Stochastic Interest Rates and Volatility, Quantitative Finance, 14, 2, 369-382, (2014) · Zbl 1294.91075
[28] Dumas, B.; Fleming, J.; Whaley, R. E., Implied Volatility Functions: Empirical Tests, Journal of Finance, 53, 6, 2059-2106, (1998)
[29] Feng, R., A Comparative Study of Risk Measures for Guaranteed Minimum Maturity Benefits by a PDE Method, North American Actuarial Journal, 18, 4, 445-461, (2014)
[30] Feng, R.; Huang, H., Statutory Financial Reporting for Variable Annuity Guaranteed Death Benefits: Market Practice, Mathematical Modeling and Computation, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 67, 54-64, (2016) · Zbl 1348.91144
[31] Geman, H.; El Karoui, N.; Rochet, J.-C., Changes of Numéraire, Changes of Probability Measure and Option Pricing, Journal of Applied Probability, 32, 2, 443-458, (1995) · Zbl 0829.90007
[32] Guillaume, F.; Schoutens, W., Calibration Risk: Illustrating the Impact of Calibration Risk under the Heston Model, Review of Derivatives Research, 15, 1, 57-79, (2012)
[33] Hardy, M. R., Investment Guarantees: Modeling and Risk Management for Equity-Linked Life Insurance, (2003), Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ · Zbl 1092.91042
[34] Hull, J. C., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives, (2014), Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ · Zbl 1087.91025
[35] Iacus, S. M., Simulation and Inference for Stochastic Differential Equations: With R Examples, (2008), New York: Springer, New York · Zbl 1210.62112
[36] Jiang, G. J.; Tian, Y. S., The Model-Free Implied Volatility and Its Information Content, Review of Financial Studies, 18, 4, 1305-1342, (2005)
[37] Kaeck, A.; Alexander, C., Stochastic Volatility Jump-Diffusions for European Equity Index Dynamics, European Financial Management, 19, 3, 470-496, (2013)
[38] Kijima, M.; Wong, T., Pricing of Ratchet Equity-Indexed Annuities under Stochastic Interest Rates, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 41, 3, 317-338, (2007) · Zbl 1141.91457
[39] Kling, A.; Ruez, F.; Ruß, J., The Impact of Stochastic Volatility on Pricing, Hedging and Hedge Efficiency of Withdrawal Benefit Guarantees in Variable Annuities, ASTIN Bulletin, 41, 2, 511-545, (2011)
[40] Kling, A.; Ruez, F.; Ruß, J., The Impact of Policyholder Behavior on Pricing, Hedging, and Hedge Efficiency of Withdrawal Benefit Guarantees in Variable Annuities, European Actuarial Journal, 4, 2, 281-314, (2014)
[41] Koopman, S. J.; Jungbacker, B.; Hol, E., Forecasting Daily Variability of the S&P 100 Stock Index Using Historical, Realised and Implied Volatility Measurements, Journal of Empirical Finance, 12, 3, 445-475, (2005)
[42] Lin, X. S.; Tan, K. S., Valuation of Equity-Indexed Annuities under Stochastic Interest Rates, North American Actuarial Journal, 7, 4, 72-91, (2003) · Zbl 1084.60530
[43] Liu, Y., Pricing and Hedging the Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefits in Variable Annuities, (2010), Ph.D. thesis, University of Waterloo
[44] MacKay, A.; Augustyniak, M.; Bernard, C.; Hardy, M. R., Risk Management of Policyholder Behavior in Equity-Linked Life Insurance, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 84, 2, 661-690, (2017)
[45] Milevsky, M. A.; Salisbury, T. S., Financial Valuation of Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefits, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 38, 1, 21-38, (2006) · Zbl 1116.91048
[46] Neumann, M.; Prokopczuk, M.; Simen, C. W., Jump and Variance Risk Premia in the S&P 500, Journal of Banking & Finance, 69, 72-83, (2016)
[47] Nielsen, J. A.; Sandmann, K., Equity-Linked Life Insurance: A Model with Stochastic Interest Rates, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 16, 3, 225-253, (1995) · Zbl 0872.62094
[48] Peng, J.; Leung, K. S.; Kwok, Y. K., Pricing Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefits under Stochastic Interest Rates, Quantitative Finance, 12, 6, 933-941, (2012) · Zbl 1279.91165
[49] Psychoyios, D.; Skiadopoulos, G., Volatility Options: Hedging Effectiveness, Pricing, and Model Error, Journal of Futures Markets, 26, 1, 1-31, (2006)
[50] Rabinovitch, R., Pricing Stock and Bond Options When the Default-Free Rate is Stochastic, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 24, 4, 447-457, (1989)
[51] Rogers, L. C. G.; Shi, Z., The Value of an Asian Option, Journal of Applied Probability, 32, 4, 1077-1088, (1995) · Zbl 0839.90013
[52] Schoutens, W.; Simons, E.; Tistaert, J., A Perfect Calibration! Now What?, Wilmott Magazine, 66-78, (2004)
[53] Thompson, G. W. P., Fast Narrow Bounds on the Value of Asian Options, (2002)
[54] Variable Annuity Hedging Survey: Sophistication Gains, Challenges Remain., Insights, (2013)
[55] Wei, X.; Gaudenzi, M.; Zanette, A., Pricing Ratchet Equity-Indexed Annuities with Early Surrender Risk in a CIR++ Model, North American Actuarial Journal, 17, 3, 229-252, (2013)
[56] Zaglauer, K.; Bauer, D., Risk-Neutral Valuation of Participating Life Insurance Contracts in a Stochastic Interest Rate Environment, Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 43, 1, 29-40, (2008) · Zbl 1140.91431
[57] Zhang, J. E.; Zhu, Y., VIX Futures, Journal of Futures Markets, 26, 6, 521-531, (2006)
[58] Zhu, Y.; Zhang, J. E., Variance Term Structure and VIX Futures Pricing, International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance, 10, 1, 111-127, (2007) · Zbl 1291.91216
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.