Market inconsistencies of market-consistent European life insurance economic valuations: pitfalls and practical solutions. (English) Zbl 1394.91233

Summary: The Solvency II directive has introduced a specific so-called risk-neutral framework to valuate economic accounting quantities throughout European life insurance companies. The adaptation of this theoretical notion for regulatory purposes requires the addition of a specific criterion, namely market-consistency, in order to objectify the choice of the valuation probability measure. This paper points out and fixes some of the major risk sources embedded in the current regulatory life insurance valuation scheme. We compare actuarial and financial valuation schemes. We then first address operational issues and potential market manipulation sources in life insurance, induced by both theoretical and regulatory pitfalls. For example, we show that the economic own funds of a representative French life insurance company can vary by almost 140%, as already observed by market practitioners, when the interest rate model is calibrated in October or on the 31st of December. We then propose various modifications of the current implementation, including a first product-specific valuation scheme, to limit the impact of these market-inconsistencies.


91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
62P05 Applications of statistics to actuarial sciences and financial mathematics
Full Text: DOI HAL


[1] Abrantes-Metz, RM; Kraten, M; Metz, AD; Seow, GS, LIBOR manipulation?, J Bank Financ, 36, 136-150, (2012)
[2] Abrantes-Metz, RM; Villas-Boas, SB; Judge, G, Tracking the LIBOR rate, Appl Econ Lett, 18, 893-899, (2011)
[3] Black, F; Scholes, M, The pricing of options and corporate liabilities, J Political Econ, 81, 637-654, (1973) · Zbl 1092.91524
[4] Bonnin, F; Planchet, F; Juillard, M, Best estimate calculations of savings contracts by closed formulas: application to the ORSA, Eur Actuar J, 4, 181-196, (2014) · Zbl 1304.91093
[5] Brigo D, Mercurio F (2006) Interest rate models-theory and practice: with smile, inflation and credit, vol. 2. Springer · Zbl 1109.91023
[6] CFO Forum (2009) Market consistent embedded value principles. http://www.cfoforum.nl/downloads/MCEV_Principles_and_Guidance_October_2009.pdf. Accessed 26 June 2016
[7] Chen, H; Singal, V, A December effect with tax-gain selling?, Financ Anal J, 59, 78-90, (2003)
[8] Christensen, JH; Diebold, FX; Rudebusch, GD, An arbitrage-free generalized Nelson-Siegel term structure model, Econom J, 12, c33-c64, (2009) · Zbl 1179.91246
[9] Christensen, JH; Diebold, FX; Rudebusch, GD, The affine arbitrage-free class of Nelson-Siegel term structure models, J Econom, 164, 4-20, (2011) · Zbl 1441.62261
[10] Coroneo, L; Nyholm, K; Vidova-Koleva, R, How arbitrage-free is the Nelson-Siegel model?, J Empir Financ, 18, 393-407, (2011)
[11] Danielsson J, Jong F, Laux C, Laeven R, Perotti E, Wüthrich M (2011) A prudential regulatory issue at the heart of Solvency II. VOX policy note
[12] Delcour IG (2012) On the use of risk-free rates in the discounting of insurance cash flows, PhD thesis, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
[13] Devineau, L; Loisel, S, Construction d’un algorithme d’accélération de la méthode des “simulations dans LES simulations” pour le calcul du capital économique solvabilité II, Bull Franç d’Actuar, 10, 188-221, (2009)
[14] Dybvig, PH; Ingersoll, JE; Ross, SA, Long forward and zero-coupon rates can never fall, J Bus, 69, 1-25, (1996)
[15] EIOPA (2010) Quantitative impact study 5—technical specifications
[16] EIOPA (2016) Technical documentation of the methodology to derive EIOPA’s risk free interest rate term structures. https://eiopa.europa.eu/regulation-supervision/insurance/solvency-ii-technical-information/risk-free-interest-rate-term-structures. Accessed 26 June 2016
[17] Karoui, N; Frachot, A; Geman, H, On the behavior of long zero coupon rates in a no arbitrage framework, Rev Derivativ Res, 1, 351-370, (1997)
[18] Floreani, A, Risk margin estimation through the cost of capital approach: some conceptual issues, Geneva Pap Risk Insur Issues Pract, 36, 226-253, (2011)
[19] Glasserman P (2004) Monte Carlo methods in financial engineering. Springer · Zbl 1038.91045
[20] Hirt GA, Block SB (2006) Fundamentals of investment management. McGraw Hill
[21] Hull, JC; White, A, Forward rate volatilities, swap rate volatilities, and the implementation of the LIBOR market model, J Fixed Income, 10, 46-62, (2000)
[22] Kemp M (2009) Market consistency: model calibration in imperfect markets. Wiley
[23] Kreps, DM, Arbitrage and equilibrium in economies with infinitely many commodities, J Math Econ, 8, 15-35, (1981) · Zbl 0454.90010
[24] Kroese DP, Taimre T, Botev ZI (2013) Handbook of Monte Carlo methods. Wiley · Zbl 1213.65001
[25] Lakonishok, J; Smidt, S, Are seasonal anomalies real? A ninety-year perspective, Rev Financ Stud, 1, 403-425, (1988)
[26] Malamud, S; Trubowitz, E; Wüthrich, MV, Market consistent pricing of insurance products, ASTIN Bul Actuar Stud Non Life Insur, 38, 483, (2008) · Zbl 1256.91018
[27] Markowitz, H, Portfolio selection, J Financ, 7, 77-91, (1952)
[28] Martin, P; Rey, H, Financial super-markets: size matters for asset trade, J Int Econ, 64, 335-361, (2004)
[29] Merton, RC, Theory of rational option pricing, Bell Jo Econ Manag Sci, 4, 141-183, (1973) · Zbl 1257.91043
[30] Moehr, C, Market-consistent valuation of insurance liabilities by cost of capital, Astin Bull, 41, 315-341, (2011) · Zbl 1239.91082
[31] Mukerji, S; Tallon, J-M, Ambiguity aversion and incompleteness of financial markets, Rev Econ Stud, 68, 883-904, (2001) · Zbl 1051.91047
[32] Rebonato, R, On the simultaneous calibration of multi-factor log-normal interest-rates models to black volatilities and to the correlation matrix, J Comput Financ, 2, 5-27, (1999)
[33] Schubert, T; Grießmann, G, Solvency II = basel II+ X, Versicherungswirtschaft, 18, 1399-1402, (2004)
[34] Sheldon, TJ; Smith, AD, Market consistent valuation of life assurance business, Br Actuar J, 10, 543-605, (2004)
[35] Söderlind, P; Svensson, L, New techniques to extract market expectations from financial instruments, J Monet Econ, 40, 383-429, (1997)
[36] Sum, V, The January and size effects on stock returns: more evidence, Int J Appl Account Financ, 1, 47-52, (2010)
[37] Turc J, Ungari S (2009) Filtering the interest rate curve, the MENIR framework. Soc Gen Cross Asset Res
[38] Vedani, J; Devineau, L, Solvency assessment within the ORSA framework: issues and quantitative methodologies, Bull Franç d’Actuar, 13, 35-71, (2013)
[39] Wüthrich M V, Bühlmann H, Furrer H (2008) Market-consistent actuarial valuation. Springer · Zbl 1172.91004
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.