Maximizing the utility of consumption with commutable life annuities. (English) Zbl 1284.91275

Summary: The purpose of this paper is to reveal the relation between commutability of life annuities and retirees’ willingness to annuitize. To this end, we assume the existence of commutable life annuities, whose surrender charge is a proportion of their actuarial value. We model a retiree as a utility-maximizing economic agent who can invest in a financial market with a risky and a riskless asset and who can purchase or surrender commutable life annuities. We define the wealth of an individual as the total value of her risky and riskless assets, which is required to be non-negative during her lifetime. We exclude the actuarial value of her annuity income in calculating wealth; therefore, we do not allow the individual to borrow from her future annuity income because this income is contingent on her being alive.{
}We solve this incomplete-market utility maximization problem via duality arguments and obtain semi-analytical solutions. We find that the optimal annuitization strategy depends on the size of proportional surrender charge, with lower proportional surrender charges leading to more annuitization. We also find that full annuitization is optimal when there is no surrender charge or when the retiree is very risk averse. Surprisingly, we find that in the case for which the proportional surrender charge is larger than a critical value, it is optimal for the retiree to behave as if annuities are not commutable. We provide numerical examples to illustrate our results.


91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
Full Text: DOI


[1] Bayraktar, E.; Hu, X.; Young, V.R., Minimizing the probability of lifetime ruin under stochastic volatility, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 49, 2, 194-206, (2011) · Zbl 1218.91146
[2] Benartzi, S.; Previtero, A.; Thaler, R.H., Annuitization puzzles, The journal of economic perspectives, 25, 4, 143-164, (2011)
[3] Bowers, N.L.; Gerber, H.U.; Hickman, J.C.; Jones, D.A.; Nesbitt, C.J., Actuarial mathematics, (1997), Society of Actuaries Schaumburg, IL · Zbl 0634.62107
[4] Cadenillas, A., Consumption-investment problems with transaction costs: survey and open problems, Mathematical methods of operations research, 51, 43-68, (2000) · Zbl 0947.91042
[5] Cox, J.; Huang, C.F., Optimal consumption and portfolio policies when asset prices follow a diffusion process, Journal of economic theory, 49, 33-83, (1989) · Zbl 0678.90011
[6] Davidoff, T.; Brown, J.; Diamond, P., Annuities and individual welfare, American economic review, 95, 5, 1573-1590, (2005)
[7] Davis, M.H.A.; Norman, A.R., Portfolio selection with transaction costs, Mathematics of operations research, 15, 4, 676-713, (1990) · Zbl 0717.90007
[8] Detemple, J.; Serrat, A., Dynamic equilibrium with liquidity constraints, Review of financial studies, 16, 2, 597-629, (2003)
[9] Dixit, A.K., A simplified treatment of the theory of optimal regulation of Brownian motion, Journal of economic dynamics and control, 15, 657-673, (1991) · Zbl 0755.90009
[10] Duffie, D.; Fleming, W.; Soner, H.M.; Zariphopoulou, T., Hedging in incomplete markets with HARA utility, Journal of economic dynamics and control, 21, 753-782, (1997) · Zbl 0899.90026
[11] Dumas, B., Super contact and related optimality conditions, Journal of economic dynamics and control, 15, 675-685, (1991) · Zbl 0737.90007
[12] Egami, M., Iwaki, H., 2009. An optimal life insurance purchase in the investment-consumption problem in an incomplete market. Working Paper. June. URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/0801.0195v2.
[13] Elie, R.; Touzi, N., Optimal lifetime consumption and investment under a drawdown constraint, Finance and stochastics, 12, 299-330, (2008) · Zbl 1164.91011
[14] Gardner, J., Wadsworth, M., 2004. Who would buy an annuity? an empirical investigation. Watson Wyatt Technical Paper No. 2004-4.
[15] He, H.; Pagès, H.F., Labor income, borrowing constraints, and equilibrium asset prices, Economic theory, 3, 663-696, (1993) · Zbl 0820.90028
[16] Jang, B.-G., Koo, H., Lee, H.-S., 2009. Default risk of life annuity and the annuity puzzle. Working Paper.
[17] Karatzas, I.; Lehoczky, J.P.; Shreve, S.E., Optimal portfolio and consumption decision for a small investor on a finite horizon, SIAM journal on control and optimization, 25, 1557-1586, (1997) · Zbl 0644.93066
[18] Karatzas, I.; Ocone, D.; Wang, H.; Zervos, M., Finite-fuel singular control with discretionary stopping, Stochastics and stochastics reports, 71, 1-50, (2000) · Zbl 0979.93121
[19] Koo, H.K., Consumption and portfolio selection with labor income: a continuous time approach, Mathematical finance, 8, 1, 49-65, (1998) · Zbl 0911.90030
[20] Lockwood, L.M., Bequest motives and the annuity puzzle, Review of economic dynamics, 15, 2, 226-243, (2012)
[21] Merton, R., Optimum consumption and portfolio rules in a continuous-time model, Journal of economic theory, 3, 373-413, (1971) · Zbl 1011.91502
[22] Milevsky, M.A.; Moore, K.S.; Young, V.R., Asset allocation and annuity-purchase strategies to minimize the probability of financial ruin, Mathematical finance, 16, 4, 647-671, (2006) · Zbl 1130.91031
[23] Milevsky, M.A.; Young, V.R., Annuitization and asset allocation, Journal of economic dynamics and control, 31, 9, 3138-3177, (2007) · Zbl 1163.91440
[24] Moore, K.S.; Young, V.R., Optimal and simple, nearly-optimal rules for minimizing the probability of financial ruin in retirement, North American actuarial journal, 10, 4, 145-161, (2006)
[25] Øksendal, B.; Sulem, A., Optimal consumption and portfolio with both fixed and proportional transaction costs, SIAM journal on control and optimization, 40, 6, 1765-1790, (2002) · Zbl 1102.91054
[26] Protter, P.E., Stochastic integration and differential equations, (2004), Springer · Zbl 1041.60005
[27] Shreve, S.E.; Soner, H.M., Optimal investment and consumption with transaction costs, The annals of applied probability, 4, 3, 609-692, (1994) · Zbl 0813.60051
[28] Tahar, I.B., Soner, M., Touzi, N., 2005. Modelling continuous-time financial markets with capital gains taxes. Working Paper. URL: http://www.cmap.polytechnique.fr/ touzi/bst06.pdf.
[29] Wang, T.; Young, V.R., Optimal commutable annuities to minimize the probability of lifetime ruin, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 50, 1, 200-216, (2012) · Zbl 1243.91066
[30] Yaari, M.E., Uncertain lifetime, life insurance and the theory of the consumer, Review of economic studies, 32, 137-150, (1965)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.