Optimal surrender strategies for equity-indexed annuity investors. (English) Zbl 1156.91379

Summary: An equity-indexed annuity (EIA) is a hybrid between a variable and a fixed annuity that allows the investor to participate in the stock market, and earn at least a minimum interest rate. The investor sacrifices some of the upside potential for the downside protection of the minimum guarantee. Because EIAs allow investors to participate in equity growth without the downside risk, their popularity has grown rapidly.
An optimistic EIA owner might consider surrendering an EIA contract, paying a surrender charge, and investing the proceeds directly in the index to earn the full (versus reduced) index growth, while using a risk-free account for downside protection. Because of the popularity of these products, it is important for individuals and insurers to understand the optimal policyholder behavior.
We consider an EIA investor who seeks the surrender strategy and post-surrender asset allocation strategy that maximizes the expected discounted utility of bequest. We formulate a variational inequality and a Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation that govern the optimal surrender strategy and post-surrender asset allocation strategy, respectively. We examine the optimal strategies and how they are affected by the product features, model parameters, and mortality assumptions. We observe that in many cases, the “no-surrender” region is an interval \((w_l,w_u)\); i.e., that there are two free boundaries. In these cases, the investor surrenders the EIA contract if the fund value becomes too high or too low. In other cases, there is only one free boundary; the lower (or upper) surrender threshold vanishes. In these cases, the investor holds the EIA, regardless of how low (or high) the fund value goes. For a special case, we prove a succinct and intuitive condition on the model parameters that dictates whether one or two free boundaries exist.


91B28 Finance etc. (MSC2000)
60G40 Stopping times; optimal stopping problems; gambling theory
60H30 Applications of stochastic analysis (to PDEs, etc.)
91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
Full Text: DOI Link


[1] Campell, J.Y.; Viceira, L.M., Strategic asset allocation, (2002), Oxford University Press Oxford
[2] Cheung, K.C.; Yang, H., Optimal stopping behavior of equity-linked investment products with regime switching, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 37, 599-614, (2005) · Zbl 1129.60065
[3] Cochrane, J., Asset pricing, (2001), Princeton University Press Princeton, New Jersey
[4] Feldstein, M.; Ranguelova, E., Individual risk in an investment-based social security system, American economic review, 91, 4, 1116-1125, (2001)
[5] Fourth Quarter Index Annuity Sales (3/06), 2005. The Advantage Compendium. http://www.indexannuity.org/library.htm (Sales)
[6] Friedman, A.; Shen, W., A variational inequality approach to financial valuation of retirement benefits based on salary, Finance and stochastics, 6, 3, 273-302, (2002) · Zbl 1029.91027
[7] Friend, I.; Blume, M.E., The demand for risky assets, American economic review, 65, 900-922, (1975)
[8] Fung, H.; Li, L.K., Pricing discrete dynamic fund protections, North American actuarial journal, 7, 4, 23-31, (2003) · Zbl 1084.91506
[9] Gerber, H.U.; Pafumi, G., Pricing dynamic investment fund protection, North American actuarial journal, 4, 2, 28-37, (2000), Discussions 37-41 and 5 (1) (2001) 153-157 · Zbl 1083.91516
[10] Gerber, H.U.; Shiu, E.S.W., Pricing perpetual fund protection with withdrawal option, North American actuarial journal, 7, 2, 60-77, (2003), Discussions 77-92 and 8 (1) (2004) 96-99 · Zbl 1084.60512
[11] Hardy, M., Investment guarantees: the new science of modeling and risk management for equity-linked insurance, (2003), John Wiley New York
[12] Huang, H.; Milevsky, M.A.; Wang, J., Ruined moments in your life: how good are the approximations?, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 34, 3, 421-447, (2004) · Zbl 1188.91233
[13] Imai, J.; Boyle, P.P., Dynamic fund protection, North American actuarial journal, 5, 3, 31-49, (2001), Discussion 49-51 · Zbl 1083.60513
[14] Jeanblanc, M.; Lakner, P.; Kadam, A., Optimal bankruptcy time and consumption/investment policies on an infinite horizon with a continuous debt repayment until bankruptcy, Mathematics of operations research, 29, 3, 649-671, (2004) · Zbl 1082.91049
[15] Krylov, N.V., Controlled diffusion processes, (1980), Springer-Verlag Berlin · Zbl 0459.93002
[16] Lee, H., 2002. Pricing exotic options with applications to equity-indexed annuities. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Iowa, Iowa City
[17] Lin, X.S.; Tan, K.S., Valuation of equity-indexed annuities under stochastic interest rates, North American actuarial journal, 7, 4, 72-91, (2003) · Zbl 1084.60530
[18] Merton, R.C., Continuous-time finance, (1992), Blackwell Publishers Cambridge, Massachusetts
[19] Milevsky, M.A.; Moore, K.S.; Young, V.R., Asset allocation and annuity-purchase strategies to minimize the probability of financial ruin, Mathematical finance, 16, 4, 647-671, (2006) · Zbl 1130.91031
[20] Milevsky, M.A., Young, V.R., 2003. Annuitization and asset allocation. Working Paper. Individual Finance and Insurance Decisions Centre, Schulich School of Business, York University
[21] Mitchell, O.S.; Poterba, J.M.; Warshawsky, M.J.; Brown, J.R., New evidence on the moneys worth of individual annuities, American economic review, 89, 5, 1299-1318, (1999)
[22] Moore, K.S.; Young, V.R., Optimal design of a perpetual equity-indexed annuity, North American actuarial journal, 9, 1, 57-72, (2005) · Zbl 1085.60512
[23] Moore, K.S.; Young, V.R., Pricing equity-indexed pure endowments via the principle of equivalent utility, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 33, 497-516, (2003) · Zbl 1103.91370
[24] Øksendal, B., Stochastic differential equations: an introduction with applications, (2000), Springer-Verlag Berlin
[25] Pratt, J.W., Risk aversion in the small and in the large, Econometrica, 32, 122-136, (1964) · Zbl 0132.13906
[26] Tiong, S., Valuing equity-indexed annuities, North American actuarial journal, 4, 4, 149-163, (2000), Discussions 163-170 and 5 (3) (2001) 133-136 · Zbl 1083.62545
[27] Wilmott, P.; Dewynne, J.; Howison, S., Option pricing: mathematical models and computation, (2000), Oxford Financial Press Oxford
[28] Young, V.R., Equity-indexed life insurance: pricing and reserving using the principle of equivalent utility, North American actuarial journal, 7, 1, 68-86, (2003) · Zbl 1084.91521
[29] Young, V.R.; Zariphopoulou, T., Pricing dynamic insurance risks using the principle of equivalent utility, Scandinavian actuarial journal, 4, 246-279, (2002) · Zbl 1039.91049
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.