×

zbMATH — the first resource for mathematics

Valuation of intergenerational transfers in funded collective pension schemes. (English) Zbl 1152.91587
Summary: This paper applies contingent claim analysis to value pension contracts for real-life collective pension plans with intergenerational risk sharing and offering DB-like benefits. We rewrite the balance sheet of such a pension fund as an aggregate of embedded generational options. This implies that a pension fund is a zero-sum game in value terms, so any policy change inevitably leads to value transfers between generations. We explore intergenerational value transfers that may arise from a plan redesign or from changes in funding policy and risk sharing rules. We develop a stochastic framework which accounts for time-varying investment opportunities and computes the embedded generational options. Changes in the values of the generational options enable us to evaluate the impact of policy modifications in the pension contract with respect to intergenerational transfers and redistribution. We find that a switch to a less risky asset mix is beneficial to elderly members at the expense of younger members who lose value. A reallocation of risk bearing from a plan with flexible contributions and fixed benefits to a plan with fixed contributions and flexible benefits leads to value redistribution from older plan members to younger ones.

MSC:
91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)
PDF BibTeX XML Cite
Full Text: DOI
References:
[1] Ambachtsheer, K.A., Pension revolution, A solution to the pensions crisis, (2007), John Wiley & Sons Hoboken
[2] Ang, A., Bekaert, G., 2004, The term structure of real rates and expected inflation. Working paper, Columbia Business School
[3] ()
[4] Bader, L.N., Gold, J., 2002. Reinventing pension actuarial science. Pension Section SOA, volume 14, No. 2, January 2003, Pension Forum Book
[5] Bauer, R.; Hoevenaars, R.; Steenkamp, T., Asset liability management, ()
[6] Blake, D., Pension schemes as options on pension fund assets: implications for pension fund management, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 23, 263-286, (1998) · Zbl 0920.62130
[7] Boender, C.G.E., A hybrid simulation/optimization scenario model for asset-liability management, European journal of operations research, 99, 126-135, (1997) · Zbl 0923.90013
[8] Boender, C.; Dert, C.; Heemskerk, F.; Hoek, H., A scenario approach of ALM, (2007), In Zenios and Ziemba (2007)
[9] Boeri, T., Bovenberg, L., Coeré, B., Roberts, A., 2006, Dealing with new giants: Rethinking the role of pension funds, Geneva Reports on the World Economy 8
[10] Brennan, M.J.; Xia, Y., Dynamic asset allocation under inflation, Journal of finance, 57, 1201-1238, (2002)
[11] Buiter, W.H., Generational accounts, aggregate saving and intergenerational distribution, Economica, 64, 605-626, (1997)
[12] Campbell, J.Y.; Viceira, L.M., Strategic asset allocation, portfolio choice for long-term investors, (2002), Oxford University Press
[13] Campbell, J.Y.; Viceira, L.M., The term structure of the risk-return tradeoff, Financial analysts journal, 61, January/February, 34-44, (2005)
[14] Chapman, R.J.; Gordon, T.J.; Speed, C.A., Pensions, funding and risk, British actuarial journal, 74, 605-663, (2001)
[15] Cochrane, J.H.; Piazzesi, M., Bond risk premia, American economic review, 95, 1, 138-160, (2005)
[16] Cui, J., De Jong, F., Ponds, E.H.M., 2006. Intergenerational risk sharing in collective pension schemes. Working paper Netspar, Tilburg University
[17] De Jong, F., 2005. Valuation of pension liabilities in incomplete markets. In: Netspar Discussion Papers 2005-024, December 2005, Netspar
[18] Enders, W.; Lapan, H., Social security taxation and intergenerational risk sharing, International economic review, 23, 647-658, (1982)
[19] Feldstein, M.S., Structural reform of social security, Journal of economic perspectives, 9, 2, 33-55, (2005)
[20] Gollier, C., 2007. Intergenerational risk sharing and risk taking of a pension fund. Working paper, Toulouse
[21] Gordon, R.H.; Varian, H.R., Intergenerational risk sharing, Journal of public economics, 14, 1-29, (1988)
[22] Guillén, M.; Jorgensen, P.L.; Nielsen, J.P., Return smoothing mechanisms in life and pension insurance: path-dependent contingent claims, Insurance: mathematics and economics, 38, 229-252, (2006) · Zbl 1159.91405
[23] Hári, N., Koijen, R., Nijman, Th.E., 2006. The determinants of the Money’s Worth of participation in collective schemes. Working paper Netspar, Tilburg University
[24] Hoevenaars, R.P.M.M., Molenaar, R.D.J., Schotman, P.C., Steenkamp, T.B.M., 2005. Strategic Asset Allocation with Liabilities: Beyond Stocks and Bonds. LIFE working paper, Maastricht University · Zbl 1181.91097
[25] Kocken, T., 2006. Curious contracts. Ph.D. Thesis. Vrije University, Amsterdam
[26] ()
[27] Kortleve, N.; Ponds, E.H.M., Pension deals and value-based ALM, (2006), In Kortleve et al. (2006)
[28] Kotlikoff, L., Generational policy, (), 1873-1932
[29] Krueger, D.; Kubler, F., Pareto improving social security reform when financialmarkets are incomplete!?, American economic reniew, 96, 3, 737-755, (June 2006)
[30] Leibowitz, M.L.; Kogelman, S.; Bader, L.N., Funding ratio return, Journal of portfolio management, 21, 39-47, (1994)
[31] Merton, R.C., 1983. On the role of Social Security as a Means for Efficient Risk Sharing in an Economy where human capital is not tradeable. In: Bodie Z., Shoven J.B. (Eds.), Financial Aspects of the United States Pension System. Chicago
[32] Munnell, A., Employer-sponsored plans: the shift from defined benefit to defined contribution, (), 359-380
[33] Nijman, Th.E.; Koijen, R.S.J., Valuation and risk management of inflation-sensitive pension rights, (2006), In Kortleve et al. (2006)
[34] Ponds, E.H.M., Pension funds and value-based generational accounting, Journal of pension economics and finance, 2, 3, 295-325, (2003)
[35] Ponds, E.H.M., van Riel, B., 2007. Sharing Risk: The Netherlands’ New Approach to Pensions. Working paper, 2007-5, Center For Retirement Reseach, Boston University
[36] Sharpe, W.F., Corporate pension funding policy, Journal of financial economics, 3, 183-193, (1976)
[37] Shiller, R.J., Social security and institutions for intergenerational, intragenerational and international risk sharing, (), 165-204
[38] Smetters, K., 2002. Controlling the Cost of Minimum Benefit Guarantees in Public Pension Conversions. NBER Working papers 8732
[39] Steenkamp, T.B.M., 1999. Contingent Claims Analysis and the Valuation of Pension Liabilities. Research Memorandum Vrije University, Amsterdam
[40] Teulings, C.N.; De Vries, C.G., Generational accounting, solidarity and pension losses, De economist, 127, 63-83, (2006)
[41] van Ewijk, C., Kuipers, B., ter Rele, H., van de Ven, M., Westerhout, E., 2000. Ageing in the Netherlands, CPB, The Hague
[42] Zenios, S.A.; Ziemba, T.Z., Handbook of asset and liability management, (2007), North Holland
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.