Investigating purchasing-sequence patterns for financial services using Markov, MTD and MTDG models. (English) Zbl 1091.90527

Summary: In the past, several authors have found evidence for the existence of a priority pattern of acquisition for durable goods, as well as for financial services. Its usefulness lies in the fact that if the position of a particular customer in this acquisition sequence is known, one can predict what service will be acquired next by that customer. In this paper, we analyse purchase sequences of financial services to identify cross-buying patterns, which might be used to discover cross-selling opportunities as part of customer relationship management (CRM). Hereby, special attention is paid to transitions, which might encourage bank-only or insurance-only customers to become financial-services customers. We introduce the mixture transition distribution (MTD) model as a parsimonious alternative to the Markov model for use in the analysis of marketing problems. An interesting extension on the MTD model is the MTDg model, which is able to represent situations where the relationship between each lag and the current state differs. We illustrate the MTD and MTDg model on acquisition sequences of customers of a major financial-services company and compare the fit of these models with that of the corresponding Markov model. Our results are in favor of the MTD and MTDg models. Therefore, the MTD as well as the MTDg transition matrices are investigated to reveal cross-buying patterns. The results are valuable to product managers as they clarify the customer flows among product groups. In some cases, the lag-specific transition matrices of the MTDg model give better insight into the acquisition patterns than the general transition matrix of the MTD model.


90B60 Marketing, advertising
90B50 Management decision making, including multiple objectives
Full Text: DOI


[1] Abbott, A., Sequence analysis: new methods for old ideas, Annual review of sociology, 21, 93-113, (1995)
[2] Abbott, A.; Hrycak, A., Measuring resemblance in sequence data: an optimal matching analysis of musicians’ careers, American journal of sociology, 96, 1, 144-185, (1990)
[3] Adke, S.R.; Deshmukh, S.R., Limit distribution of a high-order Markov chain, Journal of the royal statistical society B, 50, 105-108, (1988) · Zbl 0653.60058
[4] Agrawal, R., Srikant, R., 1995. Mining sequential patterns. In: 11th Int. Conf. Data Engineering, ICDE.
[5] Baesens, B.; Verstraeten, G.; Van den Poel, D.; Egmont-Petersen, M.; Van Kenhove, P.; Vanthienen, J., Bayesian network classifiers for identifying the slope of the customer-lifecycle of long-life customers, European journal of operational research, 156, 2, 508-523, (2004) · Zbl 1056.90019
[6] Berchtold, A., Estimation in the mixture transition distribution model, Journal of time series analysis, 22, 4, 379-397, (2001) · Zbl 0973.62066
[7] Berchtold, A.; Raftery, A.E., The mixture transition distribution model for high-order Markov chains and non-Gaussian time series, Statistical science, 17, 3, 328-356, (2002) · Zbl 1013.62088
[8] Berger, A.N., The efficiency effects of a single market for financial services in Europe, European journal of operational research, 150, 3, 466-481, (2003) · Zbl 1033.90061
[9] Berger, A.N.; Demsetz, R.S.; Strahan, P.E., The consolidation of the financial services industry: causes, consequences, and implications for the future, Journal of banking & finance, 23, 2-4, 135-194, (1999)
[10] Bollerslev, T.; Chou, R.Y.; Kroner, K.F., ARCH modeling in finance: A review of the theory and empirical evidence, Journal of econometrics, 52, 5-59, (1992) · Zbl 0825.90057
[11] Buckinx, W., Van den Poel, D., forthcoming. Customer base analysis: Partial defection of behaviorally-loyal clients in a non-contractual FMCG retail setting. European Journal of Operational Research. · Zbl 1132.90349
[12] Bühlmann, P.; Wyner, A.J., Variable length Markov chains, Annals of statistics, 27, 2, 480-513, (1999) · Zbl 0983.62048
[13] Chatfield, C.; Lemon, R.E., Analysing sequences of behavioural events, Journal of theoretical biology, 29, 427-445, (1970)
[14] Clarke, Y.; Soutar, G.N., Consumer acquisition patterns for durable goods: Australian evidence, Journal of consumer research, 8, 456-459, (1982)
[15] Cohen, A.; Ivry, R.I.; Keele, S.W., Attention and structure in sequence learning, Journal of experimental psychology: learning, memory & cognition, 16, 1, 17-30, (1990)
[16] Feick, L., Latent class models for the analysis of behavioral hierarchies, Journal of marketing research, 24, 2, 174-186, (1987)
[17] Felvey, J., Cross-selling by computer, Bank marketing, 25-27, (1982)
[18] Hauser, J.R.; Urban, G.L., The value priority hypotheses for consumer budget plans, Journal of consumer research, 12, 4, 446-462, (1986)
[19] Hebden, J.J.; Pickering, J.F., Patterns of acquisition of consumer durables, Oxford bulletin of economics and statistics, 36, 2, 67-94, (1974)
[20] Hopp, W., A sequential model of R&D investment over an unbounded time horizon, Management science, 33, 4, 500-508, (1987)
[21] Jonz, J., Textual sequence and 2nd-language comprehension, Language learning, 39, 2, 207-249, (1989)
[22] Kamakura, W.A.; Ramaswami, S.N.; Srivastava, R.K., Applying latent trait analysis in the evaluation of prospects for cross-selling of financial services, International journal of research in marketing, 8, 329-349, (1991)
[23] Kamakura, W.A.; Wedel, M.; de Rossa, F.; Mazzon, J.A., Cross-selling through database marketing: A mixed data factor analyzer for data augmentation and prediction, International journal of research in marketing, 20, 1, 45-65, (2003)
[24] Kasulis, J.J.; Lush, R.F.; Stafford, E.F., Consumer acquisition patterns for durable goods, Journal of consumer research, 6, 47-57, (1979)
[25] Katz, R.W., On some criteria for estimating the order of a Markov chain, Technometrics, 23, 3, 243-249, (1981) · Zbl 0485.62086
[26] Katz, L.; Proctor, C.H., The concept of configuration of interpersonal relations in a group as a time-dependent stochastic process, Psychometrika, 24, 317-327, (1959)
[27] Larivière, B.; Van den Poel, D., Investigating the role of product features in preventing customer churn, by using survival analysis and choice modeling: the case of financial services, Expert systems with applications, 27, 2, 277-285, (2004)
[28] Le, N.D.; Martin, R.D.; Raftery, A.E., Modeling flat stretches, bursts, and outliers in time series using mixture transition distribution models, Journal of the American statistical association, 91, 1504-1515, (1996) · Zbl 0881.62096
[29] Lipman, D.; Pearson, W., Rapid and sensitive protein similarity searches, Science, 22, 1435-1441, (1984)
[30] Logan, J.A., A structural model of the high-order Markov process incorporating reversion effects, Journal of mathematical sociology, 8, 75-89, (1981) · Zbl 0472.92018
[31] Lush, R.F.; Stafford, E.F.; Kasulis, J.J., Durable accumulation: an examination of priority patterns, ()
[32] MacDonald, I.L.; Zucchini, W., Hidden Markov and other models for discrete-valued time series, (1997), Chapman and Hall London · Zbl 0868.60036
[33] Martin, R.D.; Raftery, A.E., Non-gaussian state-space modelling of nonstationary time-series–robustness, computation, and non-Euclidean models–comment, Journal of the American statistical association, 82, 400, 1044-1050, (1987)
[34] Mayo, M.C.; Qualls, W.J., Household durables goods acquisition patterns: A longitudinal study, ()
[35] McBrearty, S., The sagoan-lupemban and middle stone-age sequence at the muguruk site, World archaeology, 19, 3, 388-420, (1988)
[36] McFall, J., Priority patterns and consumer behavior, Journal of marketing, 33, 50-55, (1969)
[37] Paroush, J., The order of acquisition of consumer durables, Econometrica, 33, 1, 225-235, (1965)
[38] Pegram, G.G.S., An autoregressive model for multilag Markov chains, Journal of applied probability, 17, 350-362, (1980) · Zbl 0428.60082
[39] Pyatt, F.G., Priority patterns and the demand for household durable goods, (1964), Cambridge University Press Cambridge
[40] Raftery, A.E., A model for high-order Markov chains, Journal of the royal statistical society, series B, 47, 3, 528-539, (1985) · Zbl 0593.62091
[41] Raftery, A.E., A new model for discrete-valued time series: autocorrelations and extensions, Rassegna di metodi statistici ed applicazioni, 3-4, 149-162, (1985)
[42] Raftery, A.E., Change point and change curve modeling in stochastic processes and spatial statistics, Journal of applied statistical science, 1, 403-423, (1993) · Zbl 0876.62072
[43] Raftery, A.E.; Banfield, J.D., Stopping the Gibbs sampler, the use of morphology and other issues in spatial statistics, Annals of the institute of statistical mathematics, 43, 1, 32-43, (1991)
[44] Raftery, A.E.; Tavaré, S., Estimation and modelling repeated patterns in high order Markov chains with the mixture transition distribution model, Applied statistics, 43, 1, 179-199, (1994) · Zbl 0825.62667
[45] Sabherwal, R.; Robey, D., Reconciling variance and process strategies for studying information system development, Information systems research, 6, 4, 303-327, (1995)
[46] Schwarz, G., Estimating the dimension of a model, Annals of statistics, 6, 461-464, (1978) · Zbl 0379.62005
[47] Srikant, R., Agrawal, R., 1996. Mining sequential patterns: Generalizations and performance improvements. IBM Almaden Research Center Paper.
[48] Srivastava, R.; Shocker, A.D., Strategic challenges in the financial services industry, ()
[49] Stafford, E.F.; Kasulis, J.J.; Lush, R.F., Consumer-behavior in accumulating household financial assets, Journal of business research, 10, 4, 397-417, (1982)
[50] Van den Poel, D.; Larivière, B., Customer attrition analysis for financial services using proportional hazard models, European journal of operational research, 157, 1, 196-217, (2004) · Zbl 1106.91318
[51] Van den Poel, D.; De Schamphelaere, J.; Wets, G., Direct and indirect effects of retail promotions on sales and profits in the do-it-yourself market, Expert systems with applications, 27, 1, 53-62, (2004)
[52] Weinberger, M.J.; Rissanen, J.J.; Feder, M., A universal finite memory source, IEEE transactions on information theory, 41, 3, 643-652, (1995) · Zbl 0820.94002
[53] Wong, C.S.; Li, W.K., On a mixture autoregression model, Journal of the royal statistical society B, 62, 95-115, (2000)
[54] Xu, J.G.; Agrawal, R., Membrane separation process analysis and design strategies based on thermodynamic efficiency of permeation, Chemical engineering science, 51, 3, 365-385, (1996)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.