×

zbMATH — the first resource for mathematics

Multicriteria analysis for agricultural resource management: A critical survey and future perspectives. (English) Zbl 0961.90041
Summary: This paper reviews multicriteria analysis applied to agricultural resource management. The applications utilize either methods for selecting multiattribute discrete alternatives (including multiattribute utility theory) or methods for solving multiobjective planning problems (including goal programming). Our main purpose is to classify and evaluate the criteria (attributes, objectives) used for modeling agricultural systems and to identify the difficulties for practitioners in applying the methodology. The fields of study in agricultural decisions requiring further investigation are also discussed.

MSC:
90B50 Management decision making, including multiple objectives
90C29 Multi-objective and goal programming
Software:
ISAAP
PDF BibTeX XML Cite
Full Text: DOI
References:
[1] J.M. Alston, P.G. Pardey, Making Science Pay: The Economics of Agricultural R & D Policy, The AEI Press, Washington, DC, 1996
[2] Antione, J.; Fischer, G.; Makowski, M., Multiple criteria land use analysis, Applied mathematics and computation, 83, 2-3, 195-215, (1997) · Zbl 0882.90087
[3] Bana e Costa, C.A.; Stewart, T.J.; Vansnick, J.C., Multicriteria decision analysis: some thoughts based on the tutorial and discussion session of the ESIGMA meetings, European journal of operational research, 99, 1, 28-37, (1997) · Zbl 0923.90091
[4] Barnett, D.; Blake, B.; McCarl, B.A., Goal programming via multidimensional scaling applied to senegalese subsistence farms, American journal of agricultural economics, 64, 4, 720-727, (1982)
[5] Bazaraa, M.S.; Bouzaher, A., A linear goal programming model for developing economies with an illustration from the agricultural sector in Egypt, Management science, 27, 4, 396-413, (1981)
[6] Benayoun, R.; de Montgolfier, J.; Tergny, J.; Laritchev, O., Linear programming with multiple objective functions: step method (STEM), Mathematical programming, 1, 366-375, (1971) · Zbl 0242.90026
[7] Berbel, J., Target returns within risk programming models: a multi-objective approach, Journal of agricultural economics, 39, 2, 263-270, (1988)
[8] Berbel, J., Analysis of protected cropping: an application of multiobjective programming techniques to Spanish horticulture, European review of agricultural economics, 16, 203-216, (1989)
[9] Berbel, J.; Gallego, J.; Sagues, H., Marketing goals vs. business profitability: an interactive multiple criteria decision-making approach, Agribusiness, 7, 6, 537-549, (1991)
[10] Berbel, J.; Rodriguez-Ocaña, A., An MCDM approach to production analysis: an application to irrigated farms in southern Spain, European journal of operational research, 107, 1, 108-118, (1998) · Zbl 0943.90045
[11] Boggess, W.; Miranowski, J.; Alt, K.; Heady, E., Sediment damage and farm production costs: A multiple-objective analysis, North central journal of agricultural economics, 2, 2, 107-112, (1980)
[12] Bouyssou, D., Some remarks on the notion of compensation in MCDM, European journal of operational research, 26, 150-160, (1986) · Zbl 0598.90057
[13] Bouzaher, A.; Mendoza, G.A., Goal programming: potential and limitations for agricultural economics, Canadian journal of agricultural economics, 35, 1, 89-107, (1987)
[14] de Wit, C.T.; van Keulen, H.; Seligman, N.G.; Spharim, I., Application of interactive multiple goal programming techniques for analysis and planning of regional agricultural development, Agricultural systems, 26, 3, 211-230, (1988)
[15] Delforce, R.J.; Hardaker, J.B., An experiment in multiattribute utility theory, Australian journal of agricultural economics, 29, 3, 179-198, (1985)
[16] Dillon, J.L.; Perry, C., Multiattribute utility theory: multiple objectives and uncertainty in ex ante project evaluation, Review of marketing and agricultural economics, 45, 1/2, 3-27, (1977)
[17] Dodd, F.J.; Donegan, H.A.; McMaster, T.B.M., Scale horizons in analytic hierarchies, Journal of multi-criteria decision analysis, 4, 3, 177-188, (1995) · Zbl 0836.90003
[18] Drynan, R.G., Goal programming and multiple criteria decision-making in farm planning: an expository analysis — A comment, Journal of agricultural economics, 36, 3, 421-423, (1985)
[19] Edwards, W.; Barron, F.H., SMARTS and SMARTER: improved simple methods for multiattribute utility measurement, Organizational behavior and human decision processes, 60, 306-325, (1994)
[20] S.A. El-Swaify, Land use planning for sustainable agriculture: are environmental conflicts inevitable? in: S.A. El-Swaify, D.S. Yakowitz (Eds.), Multiple Objective Decision Making for Land, Water, and Environmental Management, Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, 1998, pp. 9-21
[21] Farmy, D.; El-Shishiny, H., A goal programming model for desert farm planning, Advanced desert arid land technology development, 5, 69-86, (1991)
[22] Fischer, G.W., Range sensitivity of attribute weights in multiattribute value models, Organizational behavior and human decision processes, 62, 3, 252-266, (1995)
[23] Flinn, J.C.; Jayasuriya, S.; Knight, C.G., Incorporating multiple objectives in planning models of low-resource farmers, Australian journal of agricultural economics, 24, 1, 35-45, (1980)
[24] Foltz, J.C.; Lee, J.G.; Martin, M.A.; Preckel, P.V., Multiattribute assessment of alternative cropping systems, American journal of agricultural economics, 77, 2, 408-420, (1995)
[25] Ghosh, D.; Pal, B.B.; Basu, M., Determination of optimal land allocation in agricultural planning through goal programming with penalty functions, Opsearch, 30, 1, 15-34, (1993) · Zbl 0825.90670
[26] Glen, J.J., Mathematical models in farm planning: A survey, Operations research, 35, 5, 641-666, (1987)
[27] J. Granat, M. Makowski, ISAAP - Interactive specification and analysis of aspiration-based preferences, Interim Report, IR-98-052, International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, Austria, 1998 · Zbl 1068.91514
[28] Hayashi, K., Farm planning model for a truck farmer under uncertainty: A risk-averse compromise programming application, Japanese journal of farm management, 29, 1, 1-10, (1991), (in Japanese)
[29] Hayashi, K.; Kumakura, H.; Okazaki, K., Evaluating paper mulch culture of daikon (Japanese radish) by multiattribute decision analysis, Bulletin of the chugoku national agricultural experiment station, 16, 1-18, (1996), (in Japanese)
[30] K. Hayashi, Range sensitivity and inconsistency of attribute weights in agricultural research evaluation, Paper presented at the 14th International Conference on Multiple Criteria Decision Making, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA, 1998
[31] Hayashi, K., Multicriteria aid for agricultural decisions using preference relations: methodology and application, Agricultural systems, 58, 4, 483-503, (1998)
[32] Heilman, P.; Yakowitz, D.S.; Lane, L.J., Targeting farms to improve water quality, Applied mathematics and computation, 83, 2/3, 173-194, (1997) · Zbl 0908.92035
[33] Higuchi, A., Multiple goals in agricultural planning: applications of goal programming method to individual farms, Bulletin of the chugoku national agricultural experiment station C, 25, 63-108, (1979), (in Japanese)
[34] A. Higuchi, Agricultural planning to regenerate rural communities, in: The Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan (Ed.), Planning Methods for Regional Agriculture: Quantitative Approaches to Forecasting and Planning, Norin Tokei Kyokai, Tokyo, 1983, pp. 251-266 (in Japanese)
[35] H. Horiuchi, Planning for management of group farming, in: The Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan (Ed.), Planning Methods for Regional Agriculture: Quantitative Approaches to Forecasting and Planning, Norin Tokei Kyokai, Tokyo, 1983, pp. 211-228
[36] Huizing, H.; Bronsveld, K., Interactive multiple-goal analysis for land use planning, ITC journal, 4, 366-373, (1994)
[37] Kang, B.-S., A linear goal programming model for farm planning of semi-subsistence farms, Journal of rural development, 6, 1, 87-105, (1983)
[38] R.L. Keeney, Value-Focused Thinking: A Path to Creative Decisionmaking, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1992
[39] Kirkwood, C.W.; Sarin, R.K., Ranking with partial information: A method and an application, Operations research, 33, 1, 38-48, (1985) · Zbl 0569.90052
[40] Korhonen, P.J., VIG - A visual interactive support system for multiple criteria decision making, Belgian journal of operations research, statistics and computer science, 27, 1, 3-15, (1987)
[41] Lee, D.J.; Tipton, T.; Leung, P., Modelling cropping decisions in a rural developing country: A multiple-objective programming approach, Agricultural systems, 49, 2, 101-111, (1995)
[42] D. Ma, X. Zheng, 9/9-9/1 scale method of AHP, in: Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on the Analytic Hierarchy Process, Joseph M. Katz Graduate School of Business, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, 1991, pp. 197-202
[43] Maino, M.; Berdegué, J.; Rivas, T., Multiple objective programming: an application for analysis and evaluation of peasant economy of the VIII region of Chile, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 387-397, (1993)
[44] Manos, B.D., Farm planning with multiple objectives: an application of compromise programming in Greece, Agricoltura mediterranea, 121, 3, 224-238, (1991)
[45] Manos, B.; Gavezos, E., A multiobjective programming model for farm regional planning in northern Greece, Quarterly journal of international agriculture, 34, 1, 32-52, (1995)
[46] Marten, G.G.; Sancholuz, L.A., Ecological land-use planning and carrying capacity evaluation in the jalapa region (veracruz, Mexico), Agro-ecosystems, 8, 83-124, (1982)
[47] Millan, J.S.; Berbel, J., A multicriteria model for irrigated agricultural planning under economic and technical risk, Agricultural systems, 44, 1, 105-117, (1994)
[48] R.B. Myerson, Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1991 · Zbl 0729.90092
[49] H. Nakayama, Aspiration level approach to interactive multi-objective programming and its applications, in: P.M. Pardalos, Y. Siskos, C. Zopounidis (Eds.), Advances in Multicriteria Analysis, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1996, pp. 147-174 · Zbl 0868.90101
[50] Nibbering, J.W.; van Rheenen, T., The development of a quantitative method for setting research priorities: A critical assessment, Agricultural systems, 56, 2, 145-165, (1998)
[51] P. Nijkamp, J. Spronk, Interactive multiple goal programming, in: G. Fandel, T. Gal (Eds.), Multiple Criteria Decision Making: Theory and Application, Springer, Berlin, 1980, pp. 278-293 · Zbl 0434.90092
[52] Okoruwa, V.; Jabbar, M.A.; Akinwumi, J.A., Crop-livestock competition in the west african derived savanna: application of a multi-objective programming model, Agricultural systems, 52, 4, 439-453, (1996)
[53] Pal, B.B.; Basu, I., Selection of appropriate priority structure for optimal land allocation in agricultural planning through goal programming, Indian journal of agricultural economics, 51, 3, 343-354, (1996)
[54] Pétry, F., Who is afraid of choices? A proposal for multi-criteria analysis as a tool for decision-making support in development planning, Journal of international development, 2, 2, 209-231, (1990)
[55] Piech, B.; Rehman, T., Application of multiple criteria decision making methods to farm planning: A case study, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 305-319, (1993)
[56] Pöyhönen, M.A.; Hämäläinen, R.P.; Salo, A.A., An experiment on the numerical modeling of verbal ratio statements, Journal of multi-criteria decision analysis, 6, 1, 1-10, (1997) · Zbl 0892.90001
[57] Pöyhönen, M.A.; Hämäläinen, R.P., Notes on the weighting biases in value trees, Journal of behavioral decision making, 11, 139-150, (1998)
[58] Prathapar, S.A.; Meyer, W.S.; Madden, J.C., SWAGMAN options: A hierarchical multicriteria framework to identify profitable land use that minimize water table rise and salinization, Applied mathematics and computation, 83, 2/3, 217-240, (1997) · Zbl 0938.92036
[59] H. Raiffa, The Art and Science of Negotiation, Belknap Press, Cambridge, MA, 1982
[60] Rausser, G.C.; Yassour, J., Multiattribute utility analysis: the case of filipino Rice policy, American journal of agricultural economics, 63, 4, 484-494, (1981)
[61] Rehman, T.; Romero, C., The application of the MCDM paradigm to the management of agricultural systems: some basic considerations, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 239-255, (1993)
[62] Romero, C.; Amador, F.; Barco, A., Multiple objectives in agricultural planning: A compromise programming application, American journal of agricultural economics, 69, 1, 78-86, (1987)
[63] Romero, C.; Rehman, T., Goal programming and multiple criteria decision-making in farm planning: an expository analysis, Journal of agricultural economics, 35, 2, 177-190, (1984)
[64] Romero, C.; Rehman, T., Goal programming and multiple criteria decision-making in farm planning: an expository analysis – a reply, Journal of agricultural economics, 36, 3, 425-427, (1985)
[65] Romero, C.; Rehman, T., Goal programming and multiple criteria decision-making in farm planning: some extensions, Journal of agricultural economics, 36, 2, 171-185, (1985)
[66] Romero, C.; Rehman, T., Natural resource management and the use of multiple criteria decision-making techniques: A review, European review of agricultural economics, 14, 1, 6-89, (1987)
[67] Rosato, P.; Stellin, G., A multi-criteria approach to territorial management: the case of the caorle and bibione lagoon nature park, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 399-417, (1993)
[68] Sankhayan, P.L.; Prihar, R.S.; Cheema, H.S., Developing optimum cropping plans for a typical punjab farm with multiple objectives by using compromise programming, Indian journal of agricultural economics, 43, 2, 163-174, (1988)
[69] Saygideger, O.; Heady, E.O.; Vocke, G.F.; Sposito, V.A., An analysis of trade-offs in food production costs and soil conservation by an interregional programming and multigoal model, Water, air and soil pollution, 14, 69-80, (1980)
[70] Sinha, S.B.; Rao, K.A.; Mangarj, B.K., Fuzzy goal programming in multi-criteria decision systems: A case study in agricultural planning, Socio-economic planning sciences, 22, 2, 93-101, (1988)
[71] Siskos, Y.; Despotis, D.K.; Ghediri, M., Multiobjective modelling for regional agricultural planning: case study in Tunisia, European journal of operational research, 77, 375-391, (1994)
[72] Sumpsi, J.M.; Amador, F.; Romero, C., On farmers’ objectives: A multi-criteria approach, European journal of operational research, 96, 64-71, (1996) · Zbl 0926.90064
[73] Tauer, L.W., Target MOTAD, American journal of agricultural economics, 65, 606-610, (1983)
[74] Van Huylenbroeck, G., The conflict analysis method: bridging the gap between, ELECTRE, PROMETHEE and ORESTE, European journal of operational research, 82, 490-502, (1995) · Zbl 0909.90195
[75] Van Huylenbroeck, G.; Martens, L., The average value rating multi-criteria method for project evaluation in regional planning, European review of agricultural economics, 19, 2, 237-252, (1992)
[76] Varshney, K.G.; Rao, Y.P., Multiobjective crop planning using goal planning: A case study, Journal of the institute of engineers, part AG: agricultural engineering division, 69, 2, 58-65, (1989)
[77] Vincke, P., Multicriteria decision-aid, (1992), Wiley Chichester
[78] von Nitzsch, R.; Weber, M., The effect of attribute ranges on weights in multiattribute utility measurements, Management science, 39, 8, 937-943, (1993) · Zbl 0800.90071
[79] von Winterfeldt, D.; Edwards, W., Decision analysis and behavioral research, (1986), Cambridge University Press Cambridge, England
[80] Wheeler, B.M.; Russell, J.R.M., Goal programming and agricultural planning, Operational research quarterly, 28, 1, 21-32, (1977)
[81] Willis, C.E.; Perlack, R.D., A comparison of generating techniques and goal programming for public investment, multiple objective decision making, American journal of agricultural economics, 62, 1, 67-74, (1980)
[82] Willis, C.E.; Willis, M.S., Multiple criteria and nearly optimal solutions in greenhouse management, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 289-303, (1993)
[83] Yakowitz, D.S.; Lane, L.J.; Szidarovszky, F., Multi-attribute decision making: dominance with respect to an importance order of the attributes, Applied mathematics and computation, 54, 167-181, (1993) · Zbl 0778.90033
[84] Zekri, S.; Albisu, L.M., Economic impact of soil salinity in agriculture: A case study of bardenas area, Spain, Agricultural systems, 41, 3, 369-386, (1993)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.