“Scientific control” in mathematical reviewing and German-U.S.-American relations between the two World Wars.

*(English)*Zbl 0806.01032The author discusses the function of “control” exercised by scientific reviewing, juxtaposed to its other more obvious functions of “objectivity” and “modernity”; taking as a case study mathematical reviewing and German-American scientific relations between the two World Wars. This is an especially appropriate period since the first call for an American mathematical abstracting journal occurs around 1920, but the first issue of Mathematical Reviews appeared in 1940. By control the author means the function of reviewing in serving the interests of the implicit disciplinary power structures as well as social power structures. In an engaging paper the author traces vicissitudes in the relationship between German and American mathematicians over issues of reviewing, from some early American anxiety about German dominance of reviewing, through the various dissatisfactions with the Jahrbuch für Mathematik, the varying (and never uniform) American opinion on the utility of an American journal, the founding of the Zentralblatt für Mathematik, general American satisfaction with it, and the founding of Mathematical Reviews partially in response to the Nazi “Gleichschaltung” of the German reviewing journals. Nationalist reverberations in the structure of reviewing after World War II (even recently) are also briefly mentioned.

Reviewer: S.L.Segal (Rochester)

##### MSC:

01A80 | Sociology (and profession) of mathematics |

01A74 | History of mathematics at institutions and academies (non-university) |

01A60 | History of mathematics in the 20th century |

PDF
BibTeX
XML
Cite

\textit{R. Siegmund-Schultze}, Hist. Math. 21, No. 3, 306--329 (1994; Zbl 0806.01032)

Full Text:
DOI

##### References:

[1] | AAMS Archive of the American Mathematical Society, John Hay Library, Manuscript Division, Providence, RI, MS 75. |

[2] | AAMM1 AAMS, box 12, folder 51, “Report to the Council of the AMS”, April 26, 1919 (R. C. Archibald, 6 pp.). |

[3] | AAMS2 AAMS, box 12, folder 53, “Report of the Committee on Bibliography to the Council of the AMS,” April 24, 1920 (R. C. Archibald, 11 pp.). |

[4] | AAMS3 AAMS, box 27, f. 82. |

[5] | ABAS Archives of the Berlin (formerly Prussian) Academy of Sciences. |

[6] | BAP Bundesarchiv (Germany), branch Potsdam. |

[7] | BAP1 BAP, RMI, 9005. |

[8] | BAP2 BAP, REM, 2905. |

[9] | BAP3 BAP, REM, 3113. |

[10] | BP George David Birkhoff Papers, Harvard University Archives, 4213.4.5. |

[11] | GHP Gustav Herglotz Papers, University Library of Gnttingen, manuscript division, F 11 (correspondence W. Blaschke). |

[12] | HDM Harvard University Archives, UAV.561 (Department of Mathematics). |

[13] | HDM1 HDM, UAV.561.8. (Correspondence and Papers 1911-1962, Box 1911-1920). |

[14] | HDM2 HDM, UAV.561.3 (Minutes Division of Mathematics). |

[15] | OVP Oswald Veblen Papers, Library of Congress, Washington. |

[16] | OVP1 OVP, container 18, folder: abstract journal 1938-1939, part 2. |

[17] | OVP2 OVP, container 9, folder: Neugebauer 1932-1938. |

[18] | OVP3 OVP, container 3, folder: H. Bohr, Veblen to Bohr, January 8, 1951. |

[19] | OVP4 OVP, container 9, folder: Neugebauer 1938-1948. |

[20] | RCP Richard Courant Papers, New York University, Courant Institute, file: H. Weyl, Weyl to L. Ahlfors, January 14, 1948. |

[21] | RCPP Richard Courant Private Papers, in the possession of his son, Ernest Courant, Bayport, NY. |

[22] | RF Rockefeller Archives Center, Tarrytown, NY, Rockefeller Foundation, RF 1.1., series 200 D, boxes 125-126. |

[23] | RF1 RF, box 125, folder 1541, Report on the Present Status of Publication in the Mathematical Field, February 20, 1929, 7 pp. |

[24] | RF2 RF, box 125, folder 1549. |

[25] | RF3 RF, box 126, folder 1552. |

[26] | RF4 RF, box 125, folder 1550. |

[27] | RRP Roland G. D. Richardson Papers, Brown University Archives, John Hay Library, Providence, RI, correspondence. |

[28] | RRP1 RRP, folder: E. B. Wilson (1926-1930). |

[29] | RRP2 RRP, folder: J. D. Tamarkin (1940-1942). |

[30] | RRP3 RRP, separate box: correspondence 1933 (German-Jewish situation), file: O. Veblen. |

[31] | RRP4 RRP, folder: O. Neugebauer (1940-1942), Richardson to Neugebauer, December 20, 1938. |

[32] | () |

[33] | Aspray, W., The emergence of Princeton as a world center for mathematical research, 1896-1939, (), 195-215 · Zbl 0682.01015 |

[34] | Bieberbach, L., Jahrbuch über die fortschritte der Mathematik, Sitzungsberichte der preussischen akademie der wissenschaften, XXX-XXXIV, (1930) |

[35] | Birkhoff, G., The rise of modern algebra, 1936 to 1950, (), 65-85 |

[36] | Birkhoff, G., Some leaders in American mathematics: 1891-1941, (), 25-78 |

[37] | Blaschke, W., () |

[38] | Boas, R.P.; Woolf, W.B., Mathematical reviews, (), 69-89 |

[39] | Boyer, C.B., The first twenty-five years, (), 24-54 |

[40] | Curtiss, D.R., Fashions in mathematics, American mathematical monthly, 44, 559-566, (1937) · JFM 63.0020.22 |

[41] | Dalen, D.v., The war of the frogs and the mice crisis of the mathematische annalen, The mathematical intelligencer, 12, 17-31, (1990) · Zbl 0723.01006 |

[42] | Dauben, J.W., Mathematicians and world war I: the international diplomacy of G.H. Hardy and Gösta Mittag-Leffler as reflected in their personal correspondence, Historia Mathematica, 7, 261-288, (1980) · Zbl 0449.01021 |

[43] | Dresden, A., The international congress at Toronto, Bulletin of the American mathematical society, 31, 1-10, (1925) · JFM 51.0034.11 |

[44] | () |

[45] | () |

[46] | Forman, P., Scientific internationalism and the weimar physicists: the ideology and its manipulation in Germany after world war I, Isis, 64, 150-180, (1973) |

[47] | Fosdick, R.B., Hitler and mathematics, Scripta Mathematica, 9, 120-122, (1943) |

[48] | Gombrich, E.H., Style, (), 352-361 |

[49] | Grabiner, J.V., Mathematics in America: the first hundred years, (), 9-24 |

[50] | Kevles, D., () |

[51] | MacLane, S., Leadership and quality in science, (), 189-202 |

[52] | MacLane, S., Topology and logic at Princeton, (), 217-221 |

[53] | Mehrtens, H., Ludwig Bieberbach and ‘deutsche mathematik’, (), 195-241 · Zbl 0643.01013 |

[54] | Miller, G.A., Group theory reviews in the jahrbuch uber die fortschritte der Mathematik, Bulletin of the American mathematical society, 27, 459-462, (1921) · JFM 48.0041.04 |

[55] | Niven, I., The treadbare thirties, (), 209-229 |

[56] | Parshall, K.; Rowe, D., () |

[57] | Polanyi, M., () |

[58] | Reingold, N., Refugee mathematicians in the united states of America 1933-1941, Annals of science, 38, 313-338, (1981) · Zbl 0457.01016 |

[59] | Richards, P.S., The movement of scientific knowledge from and to Germany under national socialism, Minerva, 28, 401-425, (1990) |

[60] | E.C. Richardson, International Library Co-operation and Our Local Problems. Paper Read before the District of Columbia Library Association, November 17, 1926, 13 printed pp. possibly unpublished (Harvard College Library B 48.8.5). |

[61] | Sarton, G., () |

[62] | Schmidt, H.J., The rhetoric of survival: the germanist in America from 1900 to 1925, (), 204-216 |

[63] | Schröder-Gudehus, B., () |

[64] | Siegmund-Schultze, R., Theodor vahlen—zum schuldanteil eines deutschen mathematikers am faschistischen missbrauch der wissenschaft, NTM-schriftenreihe, 21, No. 1, 17-32, (1984) · Zbl 0568.01025 |

[65] | Siegmund-Schultze, R., Faschistische plane zur ‘neuordnung’ der europaischen wissenschaft: das beispiel Mathematik, NTM-schriftenreihe, 23, No. 2, 1-17, (1986) |

[66] | Siegmund-Schultze, R., Mathematics and ideology in fascist Germany, (), 89-95 |

[67] | Siegmund-Schultze, R., () |

[68] | Swerdlow, N., Memoir of O. neugebauer, Proceedings of the American philosophical society, 137, 137-165, (1993) |

[69] | America and the germans, () |

[70] | Veblen, O.; Birkhoff, George David, (), xv-xxi |

[71] | Weiner, Ch., A new site for the seminar: the refugees and American physics in the thirties, (), 190-234 |

[72] | Wilson, E.B., Insidious scientific control, Science, 48, 491-493, (1918) |

This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.