Human capital estimation in higher education. (English) Zbl 1414.62501

Summary: The concept of human capital (HC) could be defined, from an economical viewpoint, as a stock variable representing the capacity of an individual to produce a sustained flow of income due to its investment in (higher) education and work experience. This paper focuses on the empirical estimation of the graduates’ latent variable HC, composed of two principal dimensions, Educational HC and Work Experience HC, within a realistic structural model, allowing causal relationship among endogenous and exogenous indicators, taking into account possible effects of external covariates. New administrative archives and a novel methodological approach are used. The methodology is applied to estimate HC of graduates in several universities of the Milan area in the early stages of their working career. The empirical results confirm the structure of the Italian job market, where investment in HC through higher education plays only a marginal role for explaining the economic performance.


62P20 Applications of statistics to economics
62H12 Estimation in multivariate analysis
Full Text: DOI


[1] Aghion, P.; Dewatripont, M.; Hoxby, C.; Mas-Colell, A.; Sapir, A., Governance and performance of research universities: evidence from Europe and US, Econ Pol, 25, 7-59, (2009)
[2] Aguinis H (2004) Regression analysis for categorical moderators. Guilford, New York
[3] Almalaurea (2011) Condizione occupazionale dei Laureati. Consorzio Interuniversitario ALMALAUREA, Bologna
[4] Anderson, TW, Estimating linear restrictions on regression coefficients for multivariate normal distributions, Ann Math Stat, 22, 327-351, (1951) · Zbl 0043.13902
[5] Bacci, S.; Chiandotto, B.; Francia, A.; Ghiselli, S., Graduates job mobility: a longitudinal analysis, Statistica, 68, 255-279, (2008)
[6] Becker GS (1964) Human capital. Columbia University Press and NBER, New York
[7] Belzil, C.; Hansen, J., Unobserved ability and the return to schooling, Econometrica, 70, 575-591, (2002)
[8] Blundell, R.; Dearden, L.; Sianesi, B., Evaluating the impact of education on earnings: models, methods and results from the NCDS, J R Stat Soc Series A, 168, 473-512, (2005) · Zbl 1120.62109
[9] Black, DA; Smith, JA, Estimating Returns to College Quality with Multiple Proxies for Quality, J Labor Econ, 24, 701-728, (2006)
[10] Boero G, McKnight A, Naylor, Smith J (2001) Graduates and graduate labor markets in the UK and Italy. Working Paper CRENoS, Centre for North South Economic Research, University of Cagliari and Sassari, Sardinia
[11] Bougeard, S.; Hanafi, M.; Lupo, C.; Qannari, EM, From multiblock partial least squares to multiblock redundancy analysis. A continuum approach, Informatica, 22, 1-16, (2011) · Zbl 1263.62093
[12] Brunello, G.; Checchi, D., School quality and family background in Italy, Econ Educ Rev, 24, 563-577, (2005)
[13] Card, D.; Krueger, A., Does school quality matter? Returns to education and the characteristics of public schools in the United States, J Polit Econ, 100, 1-39, (1992)
[14] Card D, Krueger A (1996) Labor market effects of school quality: theory and evidence. NBER Working Paper No. 5450. In: Burtless G (ed.) Does money matter? The link between schools, student achievement and adult success. The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC
[15] Carroll J D (1968) Generalization of canonical correlation analysis to three or more sets of variables. Proceedings of the 76th Annual Convention of the Psychological Association 3:227-228
[16] Chamberlain, G.; Griliches, Z., Unobservable with a variance components structure: ability, schooling and the economic success of brothers, Int Econ Rev, 16, 422-449, (1975) · Zbl 0353.62033
[17] Checchi D, De Fraja G, Verzillo S (2014) Publish or perish: an analysis of the academic job market in Italy. Discussion Papers 14/04, University of Nottingham, School of Economics
[18] Chin, WW; Marcoulides, GA (ed.), The partial least squares approach to structural-equation modeling, 295-358, (1998), Mahwah
[19] Chin, WW; Todd, PA, On the use, usefulness, and ease of use of structural-equation modeling in MIS research: a note of caution, MIS Quart, 19, 237-246, (1995)
[20] Ciriaci, D., La fuga del capitale umano qualificato dal Mezzogiorno: un catching-up sempre pi difficile, Riv Econ Mezzogiorno, 2, 369-404, (2005)
[21] Ciriaci D (2007) Tasso di crescita naturale e crescita cumulativa nelle regioni italiane. Moneta e Credito, LX(239) 287-310
[22] Ciriaci D, Muscio A (2010) University choice, research quality and graduates’ employability: evidence from Italian national survey data. Camb J Econ 13(2):199-219
[23] Coolen H, de Leeuw J (1987) Least Squares Path Analysis with Optimal Scaling. Report RR-87-03, Department of Data Theory, University of Leiden, Holland
[24] Dagum C (2004) Human capital, income and wealth distribution models and their applications to the USA. Proceedings of the American Statistical Association, pp 253-258
[25] Dagum C (2004) Human capital. Encyclopedia of statistical sciences. Wiley, New York
[26] Dagum C, Vittadini G (1996) Human capital measurement and distribution. Proceedings of the American Statistical Association, Business and Economic Statistics Section, pp 194-199
[27] Dagum, C.; Slottje, DJ, A new method to estimate the level and distribution of household human capital with application, Struct Change Econ Dyn, 11, 67-94, (2000)
[28] Dagum, C.; Vittadini, G.; Lovaglio, PG, Formative indicators and effects of a causal model for household human capital with application, Economet Rev, 26, 579-596, (2007) · Zbl 1122.62102
[29] Davies, PT; Tso, MKS, Procedures for reduced-rank regression, Appl Stat, 31, 244-255, (1982)
[30] Pietro, G.; Cutillo, A., University quality and labour market outcomes in Italy, Labour, 20, 37-62, (2006)
[31] Pietro, G.; Cutillo, A., Degree flexibility and university drop-out: the Italian experience, Econ Educ Rev, 27, 546-555, (2008)
[32] Dijkstra, TK; Vinzi, VE (ed.); Chin, WW (ed.); Henseler, J. (ed.); Wang, H. (ed.), Latent variables and indices, Ch. 1, 23-46, (2010), Heidelberg
[33] Dotti, NF; Fratesi, U.; Lenzi, C.; Percoco, M., Local labour markets and the interregional mobility of Italian University Students, Spat Econ Anal, 8, 443-468, (2013)
[34] Földvari, P.; Leeuwen, B., An estimation of the human capital stock in Eastern and Central Europe, Eastern Eur Econ, 43, 53-65, (2006)
[35] Folloni, G.; Vittadini, G., Human capital measurement: a survey, J Econ Surv, 24, 248-279, (2010)
[36] Fornell, C.; Bookstein, F.; Fornell, C. (ed.), A comparative analysis of two structural-equation models: LISREL and PLS applied to market data, No. 1, 289-323, (1982), New York
[37] Garen, J., The Returns to schooling: a selectivity bias approach with a continuous choice variable, Econometrica, 52, 1199-1218, (1984)
[38] Garthwaite, PH, An interpretation of partial least squares, J Am Statist Assoc, 89, 122-127, (1994) · Zbl 0793.62034
[39] Glewwe, P., The relevance of standard estimates of rates of return to schooling for education policy: a critical assessment, J Dev Econ, 51, 267-290, (1996)
[40] Griliches, Z., Estimating the returns of schooling: some econometric problems, Econometrica, 45, 1-22, (1977)
[41] Hanushek, E., The Economics of schooling: production and efficiency in public schools, J Econ Lit, 24, 1141-1177, (1986)
[42] Hanushek E (2002) Publicly provided education. NBER Working Paper #8799, Cambridge, MA
[43] Hanushek E, Machin S, Wöessmann L (2011) Handbook of the economics of education, vol 4. North Holland, Amsterdam
[44] Harmon, C.; Walker, I., Estimates of the economic return to schooling for the United Kingdom, Am Econ Rev, 85, 1278-1286, (1995)
[45] Heckman, JJ, Selection bias as a specification error, Econometrica, 47, 153-161, (1979) · Zbl 0392.62093
[46] Heckman, JJ; Sedlacek, G., Heterogeneity, aggregation and market wage functions: an empirical model of self-selection in the labor market, J Polit Econ, 93, 1077-1125, (1985)
[47] Heckman, JJ; Lochner, LJ; Taber, C., Explaining rising wage inequality: explorations with a dynamic general equilibrium model of labor earnings with heterogeneous agents, Rev Econ Stat, 1, 1-58, (1998)
[48] Heckman JJ, Lochner LJ, Todd PE (2003) Fifty years of Mincer earnings regressions. NBER Working Paper #9732, Cambridge MA
[49] Hwang, H.; Takane, Y., Generalized structured component analysis, Psychom, 69, 81-99, (2004) · Zbl 1306.62437
[50] Johnes, G.; McNabb, R., Never give up on the good times: student attrition in the UK, Oxford B Econ Stat, 66, 23-48, (2004)
[51] Jöreskog, KG, A general method for analysis of covariance structures, Biometrika, 57, 409-426, (1970) · Zbl 0195.48801
[52] Jorgenson, DW; Fraumeni, BM; Lipsey, RE (ed.); Tice, HS (ed.), The accumulation of human and non-human capital 1948-1984, 227-282, (1989), Chicago
[53] Juhn, C.; Murphy, K.; Pierce, B., Wage inequality and the rise in the returns to skill, J Polit Econ, 101, 410-442, (1993)
[54] Kane, TJ; Rouse, CE, Labor-market returns to two- and four-year college, Am Econ Rev, 85, 600-613, (1995)
[55] Katz, LF; Murphy, KM, Changes in relative wages, 1963-1987: Supply and demand factors, Q J Econ, 107, 35-78, (1992)
[56] Kettenring, JR, Canonical analysis of several sets of variables, Biometrika, 58, 433-451, (1971) · Zbl 0225.62072
[57] Kiers, H.; Berge, J., Alternating least squares algorithms for simultaneous components analysis with equal component weight matrix for all populations, Psychom, 54, 467-473, (1989)
[58] ISTAT-Istituto Nazionale di Statistica (2006) L’inserimento professionale dei laureati, Roma
[59] ISTAT-Istituto Nazionale di Statistica (2009) L’inserimento professionale dei laureati, Roma
[60] Le, T.; Gibson, J.; Oxley, L., Cost- and income-based measures of human capital, J Econ Surv, 17, 271-307, (2003)
[61] Lorenz W, Wagner J (1990) A note on the returns to human capital in the eighties: evidence from twelve countries, Luxembourg Income Study Working Paper, p. 54, Luxemburg
[62] Lovaglio, PG, Process of accumulation of Italian human capital, Struct Change Econ Dyn, 19, 342-356, (2008)
[63] Lovaglio, PG, The estimation of human capital by administrative archives in a static and longitudinal perspective: the case of Milan, J Econ Surv, 24, 280-308, (2010)
[64] Lovaglio, PG; Verzillo, S.; Mezzanzanica, M., Estimation of educational returns using university and labor market administrative archives, Adv App Stat, 23, 77-105, (2011) · Zbl 06042829
[65] Lovaglio, PG; Vittadini, G.; Giudici, P. (ed.); Ingrassia, S. (ed.); Vichi, M. (ed.), Component analysis for structural equation models with concomitant indicators, (2013), Heidelberg
[66] Lovaglio, PG; Vittadini, G., Structural equation models in a redundancy analysis framework with covariates, Multivar Behav Res, 49, 486-501, (2014)
[67] McDonald, RP, Path analysis with composite variables, Multivar Behav Res, 31, 239-270, (1996)
[68] Meredith, W.; Millsap, RE, On component analysis, Psychom, 50, 495-507, (1985) · Zbl 0609.62097
[69] Murphy, KM; Welch, F., The structure of wages, Q J Econ, 107, 285-326, (1992)
[70] OECD (1998) Human capital investment: an international comparison. Centre for International Research and Innovation, Paris
[71] Oxley L, Zhu W (2002) How much human capital does New Zealand have?. Presented at Australasian Econometric Society Meeting, Brisbane
[72] Takane, Y.; Hwang, H., An extended redundancy analysis and its applications to two practical examples, Comput Stat Data Anal, 49, 785-808, (2005) · Zbl 1429.62226
[73] Nicaise, I., Human Capital, Reservation Wages and Job Competition: Heckman’s Lambda Reinterpreted, Appl Econ, 33, 309-315, (2001)
[74] Reinsel GC, Velu RP (1998) Multivariate reduced-rank regression. Springer, New York · Zbl 0909.62066
[75] Rumberger, RW; Thomas, SL, The economic returns to college major, quality, and performance: a multilevel analysis of recent graduates, Econ Educ Rev, 12, 1-19, (1993)
[76] Schönemann, PH; Steiger, JH, Regression component analysis, Br J Math Stat Psychol, 29, 175-189, (1976) · Zbl 0356.92026
[77] Sloane PJ (2001) The Impact of Research Assessment and Teaching Quality Exercise on the UK University System. Discussion Paper, Centre for European Labor Market Research
[78] Smith, J.; McKnight, A.; Naylor, R., Graduate employability: policy and performance in higher education sector in the UK, Econ J, 110, 382-411, (2000)
[79] Takane, Y.; Kiers, HA; Leeuw, J., Component analysis with different sets of constraints on different dimensions, Psychom, 60, 259-280, (1995) · Zbl 0833.62053
[80] Tenenhaus, M.; Esposito Vinzi, V.; Chatelin, YM; Lauro, C., PLS path modeling, Comput Stat Data Anal, 48, 159-205, (2005) · Zbl 1429.62227
[81] Thomas, S., Longer-term economic effects of college selectivity and control, Res High Edu, 44, 263-299, (2003)
[82] Urwin P, Di Pietro G (2003) Measuring the Impact of Higher Education Quality Inputs on the First Destination of Graduates: Do QAA Aspect Scores Add to the Explanation? Westminster Business School Working Paper 16, University of Westminster
[83] Vacca G (2013) Evaluation of the economical impact of human capital with extended redundancy. Dissertation, University of Bicocca-Milan
[84] Wollenberg, AL, Redundancy analysis: an alternative for canonical analysis, Psychom, 42, 207-219, (1977) · Zbl 0354.92050
[85] Vittadini G, Lovaglio P G (2004) The estimate of human capital from two sets of manifest indicators: formative and reflective. In: Proceedings of the American Statistical Association, Alexandria, VA
[86] Vittadini, G.; Lovaglio, PG, Evaluation of the Dagum-Slottje method to estimate household human capital, Struct Change Econ Dynam, 18, 270-278, (2007)
[87] Williams, LJ; Edwards, JR; Vandenberg, RJ, Recent advances in causal modelling methods for organizational and management research, J Manag, 29, 903-936, (2003)
[88] Willis, R.; Rosen, S., Education and self-selection, J Polit Econ, 87, s7-s36, (1979)
[89] Wold, H.; Jöreskog, KG (ed.); Wold, H. (ed.), Soft modeling: the basic design and some extensions, No. 1, 1-54, (1982), Amsterdam
[90] Wössmann, L., Specifying human capital, J Econ Surv, 17, 239-270, (2003)
[91] Wooldridge JM (2002) Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA · Zbl 1441.62010
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.