A task-specific validation of homogeneous non-linear optimisation approaches.

*(English)*Zbl 1402.92037Summary: In biomechanics, musculoskeletal models are typically redundant. This situation is referred to as the distribution problem. Often, static, nonlinear optimisation methods of the form “\(\min:\phi(\mathbf f)\) subject to mechanical and muscular constraints” have been used to extract a unique set of muscle forces. Here, we present a method for validating this class of nonlinear optimisation approaches where the homogeneous cost function, \(\phi(\mathbf f)\), is used to solve the distribution problem. We show that the predicted muscle forces for different loading conditions are scaled versions of each other if the joint loading conditions are just scaled versions. Therefore, we can calculate the theoretical muscle forces for different experimental conditions based on the measured muscle forces and joint loadings taken from one experimental condition and assuming that all input into the optimisation (e.g., moment arms, muscle attachment sites, size, fibre type distribution) and the optimisation approach are perfectly correct. Thus predictions of muscle force for other experimental conditions are accurate if the optimisation approach is appropriate, independent of the musculoskeletal geometry and other input required for the optimisation procedure. By comparing the muscle forces predicted in this way to the actual muscle forces obtained experimentally, we conclude that convex homogeneous nonlinear optimisation approaches cannot predict individual muscle forces properly, as force-sharing among synergistic muscles obtained experimentally are not just scaled versions of joint loading, not even in a first approximation.

##### MSC:

92C10 | Biomechanics |

PDF
BibTeX
XML
Cite

\textit{A. Jinha} et al., J. Theor. Biol. 259, No. 4, 695--700 (2009; Zbl 1402.92037)

Full Text:
DOI

##### References:

[1] | Abraham, L.D.; Loeb, G.E., The distal hind-limb musculature of the cat, Experimental brain research, 58, 583-593, (1985) |

[2] | Ait-Haddou, R.; Jinha, A.; Herzog, W.; Binding, P., Analysis of the force-sharing problem using an optimization model, Mathematical biosciences, 191, 2, 111-122, (2004) · Zbl 1053.92005 |

[3] | Anderson, F.C.; Pandy, M.G., Static and dynamic optimization solutions for gait are practically equivalent, Journal of biomechanics, 34, 143-161, (2001) |

[4] | Bazaraa, M.S.; Sherali, H.D.; Shetty, C.M., Nonlinear programming theory and algorithms, (1993), Wiley New York · Zbl 0774.90075 |

[5] | Bernstein, N., The coordination and regulation of movements, (1967), Pergamon Press Oxford |

[6] | Biewener, A.A.; Corning, W.R., Dynamics of mallard (anas platyrhynchos) gastrocnemius function during swimming versus terrestrial locomotion, Journal of experimental biology, 204, 10, 1745-1756, (2001) |

[7] | Biewener, A.A.; McGowan, C.; Card, G.M.; Baudinette, R.V., Dynamics of leg muscle function in tammar wallabies (M. eugenii) during level versus incline hopping, Journal of experimental biology, 207, 2, 211-223, (2004) |

[8] | Binding, P.; Jinha, A.; Herzog, W., Analytic analysis of the force sharing among synergistic muscles in one- and two-degree-of-freedom models, Journal of biomechanics, 33, 11, 1423-1432, (2000) |

[9] | Blajer, W.; Dziewiecki, Z.; Mazur, K., Multibody modeling of human body for the inverse dynamics analysis of sagittal plane movements, Multibody system dynamics, 18, 217-232, (2007) · Zbl 1178.70079 |

[10] | Buchanan, T.S.; Moniz, M.J.; Dewald, J.P.A.; Rymer, W.Z., Estimation of muscle forces about the wrist joint during isometric tasks using an EMG coefficient method, Journal of biomechanics, 26, 547-560, (1993) |

[11] | Collins, J.J., The redundant nature of locomotor optimization laws, Journal of biomechanics, 28, 3, 251-267, (1995) |

[12] | Crowninshield, R.D.; Brand, R.A., A physiologically based criterion of muscle force prediction in locomotion, Journal of biomechanics, 14, 11, 793-801, (1981) |

[13] | Crowninshield, R.D.; Brand, R.A., The prediction of forces in joint structures: distribution of intersegmental resultants, Exercise and sports sciences reviews, 9, 159-181, (1981) |

[14] | Daley, M.A.; Biewener, A.A., Muscle force-length dynamics during level versus incline locomotion: a comparison of in vivo performance of two guinea fowl ankle extensors, Journal of experimental biology, 206, 17, 2941-2958, (2003) |

[15] | Dul, J.; Townsend, M.A.; Shiavi, R.; Johnson, G.E., Muscular synergism—I. on criteria for load sharing between synergistic muscles, Journal of biomechanics, 17, 9, 663-673, (1984) |

[16] | Erdemir, A.; McLean, S.; Herzog, W.; van den Bogert, A.J., Model-based estimation of muscle forces exerted during movements, Clinical biomechanics (Bristol, avon), 22, 2, 131-154, (2007) |

[17] | Herzog, W., Force-sharing among synergistic muscles: theoretical considerations and experimental approaches, Exercise and sports sciences reviews, 24, 173-202, (1996) |

[18] | Herzog, W.; Binding, P., Predictions of antagonistic muscular activity using non-linear optimization, Mathematical biosciences, 111, 2, 217-229, (1992) · Zbl 0781.92007 |

[19] | Herzog, W.; Binding, P., Cocontraction of pairs of antagonistic muscles: analytical solution for planar static non-linear optimization approaches, Mathematical biosciences, 118, 83-95, (1993) · Zbl 0784.92003 |

[20] | Herzog, W.; Leonard, T.R., Validation of optimization models that estimate the forces exerted by synergistic muscles, Journal of biomechanics, 24, Suppl. 1, 31-39, (1991) |

[21] | Herzog, W.; Zatsiorsky, V.; Prilutsky, B.I.; Leonard, T.R., Variations in force-time histories of cat gastrocnemius soleus and plantaris muscles for consecutive walking steps, Journal of experimental biology, 191, 19-36, (1994) |

[22] | Hodgson, J.A., The relationship between soleus and gastrocnemius muscle activity in conscious cats—a model for motor unit recruitment?, Journal of physiology, 337, 553-562, (1983) |

[23] | Kaya, M.; Leonard, T.; Herzog, W., Coordination of medial gastrocnemius and soleus forces during cat locomotion, Journal of experimental biology, 206, 3645-3655, (2003) |

[24] | Kaya, M.; Leonard, T.R.; Herzog, W., Premature deactivation of soleus during the propulsive phase of cat jumping, Journal of the royal society interface, 5, 21, 415-426, (2008) |

[25] | Kaya, M.; Jinha, A.; Leonard, T.R.; Herzog, W., Multi-functionality of the cat medical gastrocnemius during locomotion, Journal of biomechanics, 38, 6, 1291-1301, (2005) |

[26] | Li, G.; Kaufman, K.R.; Chao, E.Y.; Rubash, H.E., Prediction of antagonistic muscle forces using inverse dynamic optimization during flexion/extension of the knee, Journal of biomechanical engineering, 121, 3, 316-322, (1999) |

[27] | Prilutsky, B.I.; Herzog, W.; Allinger, T.L., Forces of individual cat ankle extensor muscles during locomotion predicted using static optimization, Journal of biomechanics, 30, 10, 1025-1033, (1997) |

[28] | Roberts, T.J.; Marsh, R.L.; Weyand, P.G.; Taylor, C.R., Muscular force in running turkeys: the economy of minimizing work, Science, 275, 5303, 1113-1115, (1997) |

[29] | Schappacher-Tilp, G.; Binding, P.; Braverman, E.; Herzog, W., Velocity-dependent cost function for the prediction of force sharing among synergistic muscles in a one degree of freedom model, Journal of biomechanics, 42, 5, 657-660, (2009) |

[30] | Tsirakos, D.; Baltzopoulos, V.; Bartlett, R., Inverse optimization: functional and physiological considerations related to the force-sharing problem, Critical reviews in biomedical engineering, 25, 4-5, 371-407, (1997) |

[31] | van Bolhuis, B.M.; Gielen, C.C.A.M., A comparison of models explaining muscle activation patterns for isometric contractions, Biological cybernetics, 81, 249-261, (1999) · Zbl 0957.92013 |

[32] | Walmsley, B.; Hodgson, J.A.; Burke, R.E., Forces produced by medial gastrocnemius and soleus muscles during locomotion in freely moving cats, Journal of neurophysiology, 41, 5, 1203-1216, (1978) |

This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. It attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming the completeness or perfect precision of the matching.